Pinnacle West Capital (PNW) 10-K risk factor changes: FY2016 vs FY2015
The 2016-12-31 10-K against the 2015-12-31 one, compared heading by heading and sentence by sentence. One of these filings carries no fiscal year tag, so its year is the calendar year of the period end.
Item 1A40 rewritten27 added25 removed207 unchanged
All filing items1,525 rewritten848 added629 removed2,700 unchanged
Summary
counted, not written
- Item 1A headings could not be compared: only 0 carried over between the two years, which usually means one filing was read wrongly, so none is reported as new or removed.
- Sentence by sentence, 848 added, 629 removed, 1,525 rewritten and 2,700 unchanged across 18 items that differ.
Sentences by item
21 items, with every count and a link to each item that changed
| Item | Added | Removed | Rewritten | Unchanged | Page headers and footers changed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Item 1A. RISK FACTORS | 27 | 25 | 40 | 207 | 0 |
| Item 7. MANAGEMENT’S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS | 184 | 122 | 184 | 373 | 0 |
| Item 7A. QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Item 1. BUSINESS | 135 | 108 | 111 | 397 | 0 |
| Item 3. LEGAL PROCEEDINGS | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Cover and table of contents | 9 | 8 | 35 | 136 | 0 |
| Item 1B. UNRESOLVED STAFF COMMENTS | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Item 2. PROPERTIES | 10 | 8 | 34 | 63 | 0 |
| Item 4. MINE SAFETY DISCLOSURES | 5 | 5 | 14 | 19 | 0 |
| Item 5. MARKET FOR REGISTRANTS’ COMMON EQUITY, RELATED | 4 | 12 | 9 | 16 | 0 |
| Item 6. SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA | 0 | 4 | 42 | 12 | 0 |
| Item 8. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND SUPPLEMENTARY DATA | 464 | 314 | 997 | 1,168 | 0 |
| Item 9. CHANGES IN AND DISAGREEMENTS WITH ACCOUNTANTS | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Item 9A. CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES | 0 | 0 | 5 | 8 | 0 |
| Item 9B. OTHER INFORMATION | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Item 10. DIRECTORS, EXECUTIVE OFFICERS | 0 | 0 | 1 | 4 | 0 |
| Item 11. EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Item 12. SECURITY OWNERSHIP OF | 0 | 19 | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Item 13. CERTAIN RELATIONSHIPS AND RELATED | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Item 14. PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTANT | 0 | 2 | 8 | 9 | 0 |
| Item 15. EXHIBITS AND FINANCIAL STATEMENT SCHEDULES | 10 | 2 | 40 | 277 | 0 |
Underlined words on a shaded ground are new in FY2016; struck-through words were in FY2015. Sentences that are wholly new or wholly gone are labelled rather than marked.
Item 1A. RISK FACTORS
40 rewritten, 27 added, 25 removed, 207 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
As APS engages in these activities, we will have to demonstrate to [removed: regulators] [added: regulators, as we do with all other capital investments,] that these investments are both prudent and useful in providing electric service to customers.
APS is, or may become, subject to numerous environmental laws and regulations affecting many aspects of its present and future operations, including air [removed: emissions,] [added: emissions of conventional pollutants and greenhouse gases,] water quality, discharges of wastewater and streams originating from fly ash and bottom ash handling facilities, solid waste, hazardous waste, and coal combustion products, which consist of bottom ash, fly ash, and air pollution control wastes.
[removed: To] the [removed: extent the] rule requires the closure or modification of these CCR units or the construction of new CCR units beyond what we currently anticipate, APS would incur significant additional costs for CCR disposal.
Depending on the [removed: stringency of the] final [added: attainment designations for the new] standards and the [added: state] implementation requirements, APS may be required to invest in new pollution control technologies and to generate emission offsets for new projects or facility expansions located in ozone nonattainment areas.
APS faces [removed: physical and operational risks related to climate effects, and] potential financial risks resulting from climate change litigation and legislative and regulatory efforts to limit GHG [removed: emissions.][added: emissions, as well as physical and operational risks related to climate effects.]
[added: Potential] Financial Risks - Greenhouse Gas [removed: Regulation and] [added: Regulation,] the Clean Power [removed: Plan.][added: Plan and Potential Litigation.]
On September 11, 2013, after receiving legal advice from the ACC staff, the ACC voted 4-1 to close the current docket and await full Arizona Constitutional authority [added: before any further examination of this matter.]
One of these options would be a continuation or expansion of APS’s existing AG (Alternative Generation) - 1 [added: pilot] program, which essentially allows up to 200 MW of cumulative load to be served via a buy-through arrangement with competitive suppliers of generation.
On November 25, 2015, the ACC issued an order approving a request by several AG-1 customers and suppliers to extend the term of the program from July 1, 2016 to the conclusion of APS's [removed: next] [added: pending] general rate case.
Proposals to enable or support retail electric competition [removed: are] [added: may be] made from time to time [removed: in] [added: through ballot initiatives,] legislative or other forums in Arizona.
Effects of Energy Conservation Measures and Distributed [removed: Energy.][added: Energy Resources.]
The ACC has enacted rules regarding energy efficiency that mandate a 22% [added: cumulative] annual energy savings requirement by 2020.
A portion of APS’s total renewable energy requirement must be met with an increasing percentage of distributed energy resources (generally, small [added: scale renewable technologies located on customers’ properties).]
Customer participation in distributed energy programs would result in lower demand, since customers would be meeting some [removed: or all] of their own energy needs.
Reduced demand due to these energy efficiency [removed: and] [added: requirements,] distributed energy [removed: requirements,] [added: requirements and other emerging technologies,] unless substantially offset through ratemaking mechanisms, could have a material adverse impact on APS’s financial condition, results of operations and cash flows.
[added: Actual and Projected] Customer and Sales Growth.
For the three years [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] through [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] APS’s retail customer growth averaged 1.3% per year.
We currently [removed: expect] [added: project] annual customer growth to [added: be 1.5-2.5% for 2017 and to] average in the range of 2.0-3.0% for [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] through [removed: 2018] [added: 2019] based on our assessment of modestly improving economic conditions in Arizona.
For the three years [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] through [removed: 2015] [added: 2016,] APS experienced annual increases in retail electricity sales averaging [removed: 0.1%,] [added: 0.2%,] adjusted to exclude the effects of weather variations.
We currently [removed: estimate] [added: project] that annual retail electricity sales in kWh will increase [added: in the range of 0-1.0% for 2017 and increase] on average in the range of 0.5-1.5% during [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] through [removed: 2018,] [added: 2019,] including the effects of customer conservation and energy efficiency and distributed renewable generation initiatives, but excluding the effects of weather variations.
Actual customer and sales growth may differ from our projections as a result of numerous factors, such as economic conditions, customer growth, usage patterns and energy conservation, impacts of energy efficiency programs and growth in distributed [added: renewable] generation, and responses to retail price changes.
If our customer growth rate does not continue to improve as projected, or if [removed: it declines,] [added: we experience acceleration of expected effects of customer conservation, energy efficiency] or [removed: if the Arizona economy fails to improve,] [added: distributed renewable generation initiatives,] we may be unable to reach our estimated [removed: demand level and] sales projections, which could have a negative impact on our financial condition, results of operations and cash flows.
[removed: Damage] [added: Concerns over physical security of these assets include damage] to certain of our facilities due to vandalism or other deliberate acts [added: that] could lead to outages or other adverse effects.
The inability to successfully develop or acquire generation resources to meet reliability [removed: requirements,] [added: requirements and other] new or evolving standards or regulations could adversely impact our business.
Potential changes in regulatory standards, impacts of new and existing laws and regulations, including environmental laws and regulations, and the need to obtain [removed: certain] [added: various] regulatory approvals create uncertainty surrounding our generation portfolio.
The current abundance of low, stably priced natural gas, together with environmental and other concerns surrounding coal-fired generation resources, create strategic [removed: questions related] [added: challenges as] to the appropriate generation portfolio and fuel diversification mix.
In addition, APS is required by the ACC to meet certain energy resource portfolio [removed: requirements such as the EES] [added: requirements, including those related to renewables development] and [removed: the RES.][added: energy efficiency measures.]
The development of any generation facility is subject to many risks, including [removed: risks] [added: those] related to financing, siting, permitting, [added: new and evolving] technology, the construction of sufficient transmission capacity to support these facilities and stresses to generation and transmission resources from [added: the] intermittent generation characteristics of renewable resources.
One of these agencies, NERC, has issued comprehensive regulations and standards surrounding the security of [removed: our operating] [added: bulk power] systems, and is continually in the process of developing updated and additional requirements with which the utility industry must comply.
The increasing promulgation of NERC rules and standards will increase our compliance costs and our exposure to the potential risk of violations of the [removed: standards.][added: standards, which includes potential financial penalties.]
Certain APS power plants and portions of [removed: the] [added: certain APS] transmission lines [removed: that carry power from these plants] are located on Indian lands pursuant to leases, easements or other rights-of-way that are effective for specified periods.
APS is unable to predict the final [removed: outcome] [added: outcomes] of pending and future approvals by [added: the] applicable [added: sovereign] governing bodies with respect to renewals of these leases, easements and rights-of-way.
Palo Verde constitutes approximately [removed: 19%] [added: 18%] of our owned and leased generation capacity.
Advances in technology and equipment/appliance efficiency could reduce the demand for supply from conventional [removed: generation,] [added: generation and increase the complexity of managing APS's information technology and power system operations,] which could adversely affect APS’s business.
Widespread installation and acceptance of new technologies could [added: also] enable the entry of new market participants, such as technology companies, into the interface between APS and its customers and could have other unpredictable effects on APS’s [removed: business.][added: traditional business model.]
These trends, which have benefited from historical and continuing government [removed: subsidies] [added: support] for certain technologies, have the potential to put downward pressure on wholesale power prices throughout the western states which could make APS's existing generating facilities less economical and impact their operational patterns and long-term viability.
Like most companies in the electric utility industry, our workforce is maturing, with approximately [removed: 36%] [added: 35%] of employees eligible to retire by the end of [removed: 2018.][added: 2019.]
Investment performance, changing interest rates and other [removed: economic] [added: economic, social and political] factors could decrease the value of our benefit plan assets and nuclear decommissioning trust funds [removed: and] [added: or] increase the valuation of our related obligations, resulting in significant additional funding requirements.
Declining interest rates decrease the discount rate, increase the valuation of the plan liabilities and may result in increases in pension and other [added: postretirement benefit costs, cash contributions, regulatory assets, and charges to OCI.]
[removed: Most] [added: While most] of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act provisions have been [removed: implemented; however, costs and other effects of the legislation, which may include] [added: implemented, changes to] the [removed: cost of compliance and potentially increased] [added: Act or other potential legislation could increase] costs of providing [removed: for] medical insurance for our [removed: employees, cannot be determined with certainty at this time.][added: employees.]
To the extent
Depending on the final outcome of the pending judicial review of the Clean Power Plan, or any related legislative or regulatory activity, the utility industry may face alternative efforts from private parties seeking to establish alternative GHG emission limitations from power plants.
Alternative GHG emission limitations may arise from litigation under either federal or state common laws or citizen suit provisions of federal environmental statutes that attempt to force federal agency rulemaking or imposing direct facility emission limitations.
Such lawsuits may also seek damages from harm alleged to have resulted from power plant GHG emissions.
Co-owners of our jointly owned generation facilities may have unaligned goals and positions due to the effects of legislation, regulations, economic conditions or changes in our industry, which could have a significant impact on our ability to continue operations of such facilities.
APS owns certain of our power plants jointly with other owners with varying ownership interests in such facilities.
Changes in the nature of our industry and the economic viability of certain plants, including impacts resulting from types and availability of other resources, fuel costs, legislation and regulation, together with timing considerations related to expiration of leases or other agreements for such facilities, could result in unaligned positions among co-owners.
Such differences in the co-owners’ willingness or ability to continue their participation could ultimately lead to disagreements among the parties as to how and whether to continue operation of such plants, which could lead to eventual shut down of units or facilities and uncertainty related to the resulting cost recovery of such assets.
Changes in tax legislation or regulation may affect our financial results.
We are subject to taxation by various taxing authorities at the federal, state and local levels.
Legislation or regulation could be enacted by any of these governmental authorities which could affect the Company’s tax positions.
The prospects for broad-based federal tax reform have increased due to the results of the 2016 elections.
Any such reform may impact the Company's effective tax rate, cash taxes paid and other financial results such as earnings per share, gross revenues and cash flows.
We cannot predict the timing or extent of
such tax-related developments which, absent appropriate regulatory treatment, could have a negative impact on our financial results.
In addition to these rules and requirements, energy efficiency technologies and distributed energy resources continue to evolve, which may have similar impacts on demand for electricity.
Retail customers in APS's service territory increased 1.4% for the year ended December 31, 2016 compared with the prior year.
Retail electricity sales in kWh, adjusted to exclude the effects of weather variations, were flat for the year ended December 31, 2016 compared with the prior year.
Improving economic conditions and customer growth and an additional day of sales due to leap year were equally offset by energy savings driven by
customer conservation, energy efficiency and distributed renewable generation initiatives.
In expressing concerns about the environmental and climate-related impacts from continued extraction, transportation, delivery and combustion of fossil fuels, environmental advocacy groups and other third parties have in recent years undertaken greater efforts to oppose the permitting and construction of fossil fuel
infrastructure projects.
These efforts may increase in scope and frequency depending on a number of variables, including the future course of Federal environmental regulation and the increasing financial resources devoted to these opposition activities.
APS cannot predict the effect that any such opposition may have on our ability to develop and construct fossil fuel infrastructure projects in the future.
We have experienced, and expect to continue to experience, threats and attempted intrusions to our information technology systems and we could experience such threats and attempted intrusions to our operational control systems.
The implementation of new and additional technologies adds complexity to the information technology and operational technology systems, which could require additional infrastructure and resources.
Any potential changes and resulting cost impacts cannot be determined with certainty at this time.
In a recent appellate challenge to an ACC rate decision regarding a water company (referred to in Note 3 as "SIB"), the Arizona Court of Appeals considered the question of how the ACC should determine the “fair value” of a utility’s property, as specified in the Arizona Constitution, in connection with authorizing the recovery of costs through rate adjustors or surcharges outside of a rate case.
The Court of Appeals reversed the ACC’s method of finding fair value in that case, and raised questions concerning the relationship between fair value findings and the recovery of capital and certain other utility costs through adjustors.
The ACC sought review by the Arizona Supreme Court of this decision and APS filed a brief supporting the ACC’s petition to the Arizona Supreme Court for review of the Court of Appeals’ decision.
On February 9, 2016, the Arizona Supreme Court granted review of the decision and oral argument is set for March 22, 2016.
If the decision is upheld by the Supreme Court without modification, certain APS rate adjustors may require modification.
This could in turn have an impact on APS’s ability to recover certain costs in between rate cases.
APS cannot predict the outcome of this matter.
On January 28, 2016, an ACC Commissioner, Robert L.
Burns, sent APS a Notice of Investigation pursuant to an Arizona statute that authorizes a Commissioner and his agents to inspect the accounts, books, papers and documents of any public service corporation, and examine under oath any officer, agent or employee of such corporation in relation to the business and affairs of the corporation.
The Notice states that Commissioner Burns intends to investigate whether APS has used funds recoverable from ratepayers for political contributions, lobbying, or charitable donations purposes; whether APS’s corporate affiliates have made contributions or donations under APS’ brand name; and the degree to which APS and Pinnacle West are “intertwined” in terms of organization, management and operations.
APS intends to cooperate with this investigation to the full extent that the matter is lawfully authorized, but cannot predict its timing or outcome.
As a result of the March 2011 earthquake and tsunamis that caused significant damage to the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant in Japan, various industry organizations analyzed information from the Japan incident and develop action plans for U.S. nuclear power plants.
Additionally, the NRC performed its own independent review of the events at Fukushima Daiichi, including a review of the agency’s processes and regulations in order to determine whether the agency
should promulgate additional regulations and possibly make more fundamental changes to the NRC’s system of regulation.
As a result of the Fukushima event, the NRC has directed nuclear power plants to implement the first tier recommendations of the NRC’s Near Term Task Force.
In response to these recommendations, Palo Verde expects to spend approximately $0.5 million for capital enhancements to the plant over the next year in addition to the approximate $125 million that has already been spent on capital enhancements as of December 31, 2015 (APS’s share is 29.1%).
We cannot predict whether these amounts will increase or whether additional financial and/or operational requirements on Palo Verde and APS may be imposed.
before any further examination of this matter.
In 2010, the ACC issued a decision holding that solar vendors that install and operate solar facilities for non-profit schools and governments pursuant to a specific type of contract that calculates payments based on the energy produced are not “public service corporations” under the Arizona Constitution, and are therefore not regulated by the ACC.
The use of such products by customers within our territory results in some level of competition.
APS cannot predict when, and the extent to which, additional service providers will enter APS’s service territory, increasing the level of competition in the market.
scale renewable technologies located on customers’ properties).
Concerns over physical security of these assets is also increasing, which may require us to incur additional capital and operating costs to address.
We have experienced, and expect to continue to experience, these types of threats and attempted intrusions.
postretirement benefit costs, cash contributions, regulatory assets, and charges to OCI.
Item 7. MANAGEMENT’S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
184 rewritten, 184 added, 122 removed, 373 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
[added: (See Note 10 for information regarding challenges to the legality of the Clean Power Plan and a court-ordered stay of the Clean Power Plan pending judicial review of the rule, which temporarily delays compliance obligations.)] APS continually analyzes its long-range capital management plans to assess the potential effects of these changes, understanding that any resulting regulation and legislation could impact the economic viability of certain plants, as well as the willingness or ability of power plant participants to continue participation in such plants.
On September 11, 2014, APS announced that it would close its 260 MW Unit 2 at Cholla and cease burning coal at Units 1 and 3 by the mid-2020s if EPA approves a compromise proposal offered by APS to meet required [removed: environmental and] [added: air] emissions standards and rules.
(See Note 3 for details related to the resulting regulatory asset and Note 10 for details of the proposal.) APS believes that the environmental benefits of this proposal are greater in the [removed: long term] [added: long-term] than the benefits that would have resulted from adding emissions control equipment.
In connection with APS’s [removed: most recent] [added: prior] retail rate case with the ACC, the ACC reserved the right to review the prudence of the Four Corners transaction for cost recovery purposes upon the closing of the transaction.
The Arizona Court of Appeals [removed: has] suspended the appeal pending the Arizona Supreme Court's decision in the SIB matter discussed [removed: below, which could have an effect on the outcome of this Four Corners proceeding.][added: below.]
Concurrently with the closing of the SCE [removed: transaction,] [added: transaction described above,] BHP Billiton, the parent company of BNCC, the coal supplier and operator of the mine that serves Four Corners, transferred its ownership of BNCC to NTEC, a company formed by the Navajo Nation to own the mine and develop other energy projects.
BHP Billiton [removed: will be] [added: was] retained by NTEC under contract as the mine manager and operator [removed: until July] [added: through] 2016.
Also occurring concurrently with the closing, the Four Corners’ co-owners executed the 2016 Coal Supply Agreement for the supply of coal to Four Corners from July [removed: 2016, when the current coal supply agreement expires,] [added: 2016] through 2031.
Under the 2016 Coal Supply Agreement, APS [removed: has] agreed to assume the 7% shortfall obligation.
The [removed: cash] purchase [removed: price, which will be subject to certain adjustments at closing, is] [added: price was] immaterial in amount, and [removed: the purchaser will assume] [added: 4CA assumed] El Paso's reclamation and decommissioning obligations associated with the 7% interest.
[removed: When APS, or an affiliate of APS, ultimately acquires El Paso's interest in Four Corners,] NTEC has the option to purchase the [added: 7%] interest within a certain timeframe pursuant to an option granted [removed: by APS] to NTEC.
On December 29, 2015, NTEC [removed: notified APS] [added: provided notice] of its intent to exercise the option.
APS, on behalf of the Four Corners participants, negotiated amendments to an existing facility lease with the Navajo Nation, which extends the Four Corners leasehold interest from 2016 to [removed: 2041.]
A federal environmental review was undertaken as part of the DOI review process, and culminated in the issuance by DOI of a record [added: of decision on July 17, 2015 justifying the agency action extending the life of the plant and the adjacent mine.]
[removed: We] [added: APS] cannot predict the [removed: timing or] outcome of this [removed: matter.][added: proceeding.]
The capital expenditures table presented in the "Liquidity and Capital Resources" section below includes new APS transmission projects through [removed: 2018,] [added: 2019,] along with other transmission costs for upgrades and replacements.
APS is also working to establish and expand advanced grid technologies throughout its service [removed: territory to provide long-term benefits both to APS and its customers.]
APS is strategically deploying a variety of technologies that are intended to allow customers to better [removed: monitor] [added: manage] their energy [removed: use and needs,] [added: usage,] minimize system outage [removed: durations, as well as the number of customers that experience outages,] [added: durations] and [added: frequency, enable customer choice for behind-the-meter technologies, and] facilitate greater cost savings to APS through improved reliability and the automation of certain distribution [removed: functions, including remote meter reading and remote connects and disconnects.][added: functions.]
The renewable energy requirement is [removed: 6%] [added: 7%] of retail electric sales in [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] and increases annually until it reaches 15% in 2025.
APS met its settlement commitment and RES target for [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
On July 1, [removed: 2014,] [added: 2016,] APS filed its [removed: 2015] [added: 2017] RES [removed: implementation plan] [added: Implementation Plan] and proposed a [removed: RES] budget of approximately [removed: $154] [added: $150] million.
[removed: On] [added: In] December [removed: 19,] 2014, the ACC voted that it had no objection to APS implementing [removed: its residential] [added: an APS-owned] rooftop solar [removed: program.][added: research and development program aimed at learning how to efficiently enable the integration of rooftop solar and battery storage with the grid.]
The [removed: program will target specific] [added: first stage of the program, called the "Solar Partner Program," placed 8 MW of residential rooftop solar on strategically selected] distribution feeders in an effort to maximize potential system benefits, as well as [removed: make] [added: made] systems available to limited-income customers who [removed: cannot] [added: could not] easily install solar through transactions with third parties.
The ACC expressly reserved that any determination of prudency of the residential rooftop solar program for rate making purposes [removed: shall] [added: would] not be made until the project [removed: is] [added: was] fully in [removed: service] [added: service,] and APS [removed: requests] [added: has requested] cost recovery [added: for the project] in [removed: a future] [added: its currently pending] rate case.
[removed: The] [added: In March 2014, the] ACC [removed: also] approved a Resource Savings Initiative that allows APS to count towards compliance with the ACC Electric Energy Efficiency Standards, savings from improvements to APS’s transmission and delivery system, generation and facilities that have been approved through a DSM Plan.
In its decision, the ACC also approved that verified energy savings from APS’s resource savings projects could be counted toward compliance with the Electric Energy Efficiency Standard, however, the ACC ruled that APS was not allowed to count savings from systems savings projects toward determination of its achievement tier level for its performance incentive, nor may APS include savings from conservation voltage reduction in the calculation of its [removed: Lost Fixed Cost Recovery] [added: LFCR] mechanism.
See Note 3 for [removed: details regarding the 2012 Settlement Agreement terms and for] information on APS’s FERC rates.
As part of APS’s acquisition of SCE’s interest in [added: Four Corners] Units 4 and [removed: 5 of Four Corners,] [added: 5,] APS and SCE agreed, via a "Transmission Termination Agreement" that, upon closing of the acquisition, the companies would terminate an existing transmission agreement ("Transmission Agreement") between the parties that provides transmission capacity on a system (the "Arizona Transmission System") for SCE to transmit its portion of the output from Four Corners to California.
[removed: On October 20,] [added: In] 2015, the ACC voted to conduct a generic evidentiary hearing on the value and cost of distributed generation to gather information that will inform the ACC on net metering issues and cost of service studies in upcoming utility rate cases.
The ACC sought review by the Arizona Supreme Court of this [removed: decision] [added: decision,] and APS filed a brief supporting the ACC’s petition to the Arizona Supreme Court for review of the Court of Appeals’ decision.
APS cannot predict the outcome of this [removed: matter.][added: proceeding.]
Pinnacle West and APS currently have ample borrowing capacity under their respective credit facilities, and may readily access these facilities ensuring adequate liquidity for [removed: each company.]
[added: TransCanyon] continues to pursue transmission development opportunities in the western United States consistent with its strategy.
For the years [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] through [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] retail electric revenues comprised approximately [removed: 93%] [added: 94%] of our total electric operating revenues.
[added: Actual and Projected] Customer and Sales Growth.
Retail customers in APS’s service territory increased [removed: 1.2%] [added: 1.4%] for the year ended December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] compared with the prior year.
For the three years [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] through [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] APS’s customer growth averaged 1.3% per year.
We currently [removed: expect] [added: project] annual customer growth to [added: be 1.5-2.5% for 2017 and to] average in the range of 2.0-3.0% for [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] through [removed: 2018] [added: 2019] based on our assessment of modestly improving economic conditions in Arizona.
Retail electricity sales in kWh, adjusted to exclude the effects of weather variations, [removed: increased 0.7%] [added: were flat] for the year ended December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] compared with the prior [removed: year, reflecting the effects of improving economic conditions and customer growth, partially offset by customer conservation and energy efficiency and distributed renewable generation initiatives.][added: year.]
For the three years [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] through [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] APS experienced annual increases in retail electricity sales averaging [removed: 0.1%,] [added: 0.2%,] adjusted to exclude the effects of weather variations.
Palo Verde experienced strong performance during 2016, with the completion of two refueling outages.
The fall refueling outage was completed in 28 days with the lowest collective radiation exposure dose for any pressurized water reactor outage.
On January 13, 2017, EPA approved a final rule incorporating APS's compromise proposal.
Once the final rule is published in the Federal Register, parties have 60 days to file a petition for review in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
APS cannot predict at this time whether such petitions will be filed or if they will be successful.
In addition, under the terms of an executive memorandum issued on January 20, 2017, this final rule will not be published in the Federal Register until after it has been reviewed by an appointee of the President.
We cannot predict when such review will occur and what may result from the additional review.
On August 8, 2016, the Arizona Supreme Court issued its opinion in the SIB matter, and the Arizona Court of Appeals has now ordered supplemental briefing on how that SIB decision should affect the challenge to the Four Corners rate adjustment.
4CA purchased the El Paso interest on July 6, 2016.
2041.
On April 20, 2016, several environmental groups filed a lawsuit against OSM and other federal agencies in the District of Arizona in connection with their issuance of the approvals that extended the life of Four Corners and the adjacent mine.
The lawsuit alleges that these federal agencies violated both the ESA and NEPA in providing the federal approvals necessary to extend operations at the Four Corners Power Plant and the adjacent Navajo Mine past July 6, 2016.
APS filed a motion to intervene in the proceedings, which was granted on August 3, 2016.
Briefing on the merits of this litigation is expected to extend through May 2017.
On September 15, 2016, NTEC filed a motion to intervene for the purpose of dismissing the lawsuit based on NTEC's tribal sovereign immunity.
Because the court has placed a stay on all litigation deadlines pending its decision regarding NTEC's motion to dismiss, the schedule for briefing and the anticipated timeline for completion of this litigation will likely be extended.
We cannot predict the outcome of this matter or its potential effect on Four Corners.
Navajo Plant
On February 13, 2017, the co-owners of the Navajo Plant voted not to pursue continued operation of the plant beyond December 2019, the expiration of the current lease term, and to pursue a new lease or lease extension with the Navajo Nation that would allow decommissioning activities to begin after December 2019 instead of later this year.
Various stakeholders including regulators, tribal representatives and others interested in the continued operation of the plant intend to meet to determine if an alternate solution can be reached that would permit continued operation of the plant beyond 2019.
We cannot predict whether any alternate solutions will be found that would be acceptable to all of the stakeholders and feasible to implement.
APS is currently recovering depreciation and a return on the net book value of its interest in the Navajo Plant.
APS will seek continued recovery in rates for the book value of its remaining investment in the plant ($108 million as of December 31, 2016, see Note 9 for additional details) plus a return on the net book value as well as other costs related to retirement and closure, which are still being assessed and which may be material.
We cannot predict whether APS would obtain such recovery.
On February 14, 2017, the ACC opened a docket titled "ACC Investigation Concerning the Future of the Navajo Generating Station" with the stated goal of engaging stakeholders and negotiating a sustainable pathway for the Navajo Plant to continue operating in some form after December 2019.
(See Note 3 for proposed rate recovery in our current retail rate case filing.) On September 9, 2016, Maricopa County issued a final permit decision that authorizes construction of the Ocotillo modernization project.
territory to provide long-term benefits both to APS and its customers.
Energy Imbalance Market.
In 2015, APS and the CAISO, the operator for the majority of California's transmission grid, signed an agreement for APS to begin participation in EIM.
APS's participation in the EIM began on October 1, 2016.
The EIM allows for rebalancing supply and demand in 15-minute blocks with dispatching every five minutes before the energy is needed, instead of the traditional one hour blocks.
APS expects that its participation in EIM will lower its fuel costs, improve visibility and situational awareness for system operations in the Western Interconnection power grid, and improve integration of APS’s renewable resources.
The second stage of the program, which included an additional 2 MW of rooftop solar and energy storage, placed two energy storage systems sized at 2 MW on two different high solar penetration feeders to test various grid-related operation improvements and system interoperability, and was in operation by the end of 2016.
On September 30, 2016, APS presented its preliminary findings from the residential rooftop solar program in a filing with the ACC.
APS’s budget request included additional funding to process the high volume of residential rooftop solar interconnection requests and also requested a permanent waiver of the residential distributed energy requirement for 2017 contained in the RES rules.
The ACC has not yet ruled on the Company’s 2017 RES Implementation Plan.
In September of 2016, the ACC initiated a proceeding which will examine the possible modernization and expansion of the RES.
The ACC noted that many of the provisions of the original rule may no longer be appropriate, and the underlying economic assumptions associated with the rule have changed dramatically.
The proceeding will review such issues as the rapidly declining cost of solar generation, an increased interest in community solar projects, energy storage options, and the decline in fossil fuel generation due to stringent EPA regulations.
The proceeding will also examine the feasibility of increasing the standard to 30% of retail sales by 2030, in contrast to the current standard of 15% of retail sales by 2025.
The March 2011 earthquake and tsunamis in Japan and the resulting accident at Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power station had a significant impact on nuclear power operators worldwide.
In the aftermath of the accident, the NRC conducted an independent assessment to consider actions to address lessons learned from the Fukushima events.
The independent assessment, named the "Near Term Task Force," recommended a number of proposed enhancements to U.S. commercial nuclear power plant equipment and emergency plans.
The NRC has directed nuclear power plants to begin implementing some of the Near Term Task Force’s recommendations.
To implement these recommendations, Palo Verde expects to spend approximately $0.5 million for capital enhancements to the plant through 2016 in addition to the approximate $125 million that has already been spent on capital enhancements as of December 31, 2015 (APS’s share is 29.1%).
Completion of the purchase is subject to the receipt of certain regulatory approvals and is expected to occur in July 2016.
APS is negotiating a definitive purchase agreement with NTEC for the purchase of the 7% interest.
of decision on July 17, 2015.
The record of decision provided the authority for the Bureau of Indian Affairs to sign the lease amendments and rights-of-way renewals, which occurred in late July 2015.
On December 21, 2015, several environmental groups filed a notice of intent to sue with OSM and other federal agencies under the Endangered Species Act alleging that OSM's reliance on the Biological Opinion and Incidental Take Statement prepared in connection with the environmental review described above were not in accordance with applicable law.
We are monitoring this matter and will intervene if a lawsuit is filed.
APS completed a competitive solicitation process in which the Ocotillo project was evaluated against other alternatives.
Consistent with the independent monitor’s report, the Ocotillo project was selected as the best alternative.
APS must finalize the permitting process before construction can begin.
In 2013, the ACC conducted a hearing to consider APS's proposal to establish compliance with distributed energy requirements by tracking and recording distributed energy, rather than acquiring and retiring renewable energy credits.
On February 6, 2014, the ACC established a proceeding to modify the renewable energy rules to establish a process for compliance with the renewable energy requirement that is not based solely on the use of renewable energy credits.
On September 9, 2014, the ACC authorized a rulemaking process to modify the RES rules.
The proposed changes would permit the ACC to find that utilities have complied with the distributed energy requirement in light of all available information.
The ACC adopted these changes on December 18, 2014.
The revised rules went into effect on April 21, 2015.
On December 31, 2014, the ACC issued a decision approving the 2015 RES implementation plan with minor modifications, including reducing the requested budget to approximately $152 million.
APS has developed owned solar resources through the ACC-approved AZ Sun Program.
APS has invested approximately $675 million in its AZ Sun Program.
Agreements for the development and completion of future resources are subject to various conditions, including successful siting, permitting and interconnection of the project to the electric grid.
In accordance with the ACC’s decision on the 2014 RES plan, on April 15, 2014, APS filed an application with the ACC requesting permission to build an additional 20 MW of APS-owned utility scale solar under the AZ Sun Program.
In a subsequent filing, APS also offered an alternative proposal to replace the 20 MW of utility scale solar with 10 MW (approximately 1,500 customers) of APS-owned residential solar that will not be under the AZ Sun Program.
The first stage of the residential rooftop solar program, called the "Solar Partner Program", is to be 8 MW followed by a 2 MW second stage that will only be deployed if coupled with distributed storage.
On June 1, 2012, APS filed its 2013 DSM Plan.
In 2013, the standards required APS to achieve cumulative energy savings equal to 5% of its 2012 retail energy sales.
Later in 2012, APS filed a supplement to its plan that included a proposed budget for 2013 of $87.6 million.
On March 11, 2014, the ACC issued an order approving APS’s 2013 DSM Plan.
The ACC approved a budget of $68.9 million for each of 2013 and 2014.
The DSM Plan also proposed a reduction in the DSMAC of approximately 12%.
A formal rulemaking has not been initiated and there has been no additional action on the draft to date.
On June 1, 2011, APS filed a rate case with the ACC.
APS and other parties to the retail rate case subsequently entered into the 2012 Settlement Agreement detailing the terms upon which the parties have agreed to settle the rate case.
On January 29, 2016, APS filed a NOI informing the ACC that APS intends to submit a rate case application in June 2016 using an adjusted test year ending December 31, 2015.
The NOI provides an overview of the key issues APS expects to address in its formal request such as rate design changes (residential, commercial and industrial), a decoupling mechanism, permission to defer for potential future recovery costs associated with the Company’s Ocotillo Modernization Project, permission to defer for potential future recovery costs associated with environmental standards compliance, inclusion of post-test year plant and modifications to certain adjustor mechanisms, among other items.
In its rate application, APS will request that its proposed pricing changes take effect in July 2017.
APS is still developing the exact amount of the request.
An excerpt. Shown here: 40 of 184 rewritten, 40 of 184 added and 40 of 122 removed. The counts are complete. For every sentence, read Item 7. MANAGEMENT’S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS in the FY2016 filing and the FY2015 filing.
Item 1. BUSINESS
111 rewritten, 135 added, 108 removed, 397 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Pinnacle West’s other subsidiaries are El [removed: Dorado] [added: Dorado, BCE] and [removed: BCE.][added: 4CA.]
We own or lease [removed: 6,186] [added: 6,236] MW of regulated generation capacity and we hold a mix of both long-term and short-term purchased power agreements for additional capacity, including a variety of agreements for the purchase of renewable energy.
During [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] no single purchaser or user of energy accounted for more than [removed: 1.3%] [added: 1.1%] of our electric revenues.
[removed: ][added: ]
APS’s sources of energy by type used to supply energy to Native Load customers during [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] were as follows:
[removed: ][added: ]
Four Corners — Four Corners [removed: was originally a 5-unit coal-fired power plant, which] is located in the northwestern corner of New [removed: Mexico.][added: Mexico, and was originally a 5-unit coal-fired power plant.]
APS operates the plant and owns [removed: 100% of Four Corners Units 1, 2 and 3 and] 63% of Four Corners Units 4 and 5 following the acquisition of SCE’s interest in Units 4 and 5 described below.
[removed: As of December 30, 2013,] APS [removed: retired] [added: owns 100% of] Units 1, 2 and [removed: 3.][added: 3, which were retired as of December 30, 2013.]
The final purchase price for [removed: SCE’s] [added: the] interest was approximately $182 million.
[removed: In connection with APS’s most recent retail] rate case with the ACC, the ACC reserved the right to review the prudence of the Four Corners [added: transaction for cost recovery purposes upon the closing of the transaction.]
On February 23, 2015, the ACC decision approving the rate [removed: adjustment] [added: adjustments] was appealed.
The Arizona Court of Appeals [removed: has] suspended the appeal pending the Arizona Supreme Court's decision in the [removed: SIB] [added: System Improvement Benefits ("SIB")] matter discussed in Note [removed: 3, which could have an effect on the outcome of this Four Corners proceeding.][added: 3.]
BHP Billiton [removed: will be] [added: was] retained by NTEC under contract as the mine manager and operator [removed: until July] [added: through] 2016.
Also occurring concurrently with the closing, the Four Corners’ co-owners executed a long-term agreement for the supply of coal to Four Corners from July [removed: 2016, when the current coal supply agreement expires,] [added: 2016] through 2031 (the [removed: “2016] [added: "2016] Coal Supply [removed: Agreement”).][added: Agreement").]
Under the 2016 Coal Supply Agreement, APS [removed: has] agreed to assume the 7% shortfall obligation.
The [removed: cash] purchase [removed: price, which will be subject to certain adjustments at closing, is] [added: price was] immaterial in amount, and [removed: the purchaser will assume] [added: 4CA assumed] El Paso's reclamation and decommissioning obligations associated with the 7% interest.
[removed: When APS, or an affiliate of APS, ultimately acquires El Paso's interest in Four Corners,] NTEC has the option to purchase the [added: 7%] interest within a certain timeframe pursuant to an option granted [removed: by APS] to NTEC.
On December 29, 2015, NTEC [removed: notified APS] [added: provided notice] of its intent to exercise the option.
A federal environmental review was undertaken as part of the DOI review [removed: process] [added: process,] and culminated in the issuance by [removed: the] DOI of a record of decision on July 17, [removed: 2015.][added: 2015 justifying the agency action extending the life of the plant and the adjacent mine.]
[removed: We] [added: APS] cannot predict the [removed: timing or] outcome of this [removed: matter.][added: proceeding.]
[removed: PacifiCorp owns Cholla Unit 4,] and APS operates that unit for PacifiCorp.
(See Note 3 for details related to the resulting regulatory asset and Note 10 for details of the proposal.) APS believes that the environmental benefits of this proposal are greater in the [removed: long term] [added: long-term] than the benefits that would have resulted from adding the emissions control equipment.
APS purchases all of Cholla’s coal requirements from a coal [removed: supplier] [added: supplier, an affiliate of Peabody Energy Corporation,] that mines all of the coal under long-term leases of coal reserves with the federal and state governments and private landholders.
[removed: In addition,] APS has a long-term coal transportation [added: by rail] contract that [removed: runs through] [added: expires in] 2017.
[removed: See "Current] [added: (See “Energy Sources] and [removed: Future Resources] [added: Resource Planning] - [removed: Future Resources] [added: Current] and [removed: Resource Plan" below] [added: Future Resources” above] for [removed: a discussion] [added: details] of [removed: future] [added: these] plans [removed: for Cholla.][added: and]
The [removed: length] [added: exercise] of the renewal options resulted in APS retaining the assets through 2023 under one lease and 2033 under the other two leases.
The participants have also contracted for 100% of Palo Verde’s enrichment services through 2020 and 20% of its enrichment services for 2021-2026; and all of Palo Verde’s fuel assembly fabrication services through [removed: 2022.][added: 2024.]
APS Lawsuit for Breach of Standard Contract — In December 2003, APS, acting on behalf of itself and the participant owners of Palo Verde, filed a lawsuit against DOE in the [removed: U.S.] [added: United States] Court of Federal Claims [added: ("Court of Federal Claims")] for damages incurred due to DOE’s breach of the Standard Contract.
On December 19, 2012, APS, acting on behalf of itself and the participant owners of Palo Verde, filed a second breach of contract lawsuit against the [removed: DOE.][added: DOE in the Court of Federal Claims.]
This lawsuit sought to recover damages incurred due to DOE’s [removed: failure] [added: breach of the Standard Contract for failing] to accept Palo Verde’s spent nuclear fuel [removed: for the period beginning] [added: and high level waste from] January 1, 2007 through June 30, [removed: 2011.][added: 2011, as it was required to do pursuant to the terms of the Standard Contract and the Nuclear Waste Policy Act.]
On August 18, 2014, APS and DOE entered into a settlement agreement, stipulating to a dismissal of the lawsuit and payment of $57.4 million by DOE to the Palo Verde owners for certain specified [added: costs incurred by Palo Verde during the period January 1, 2007 through June 30, 2011.]
[removed: APS’s second] [added: APS's next] claim [removed: made] pursuant to the terms of the August 18, [removed: 2014,] [added: 2014] settlement [removed: agreement, which] [added: agreement] was [removed: for] [added: submitted to] the [removed: period July 1, 2014 through June 30, 2015,] [added: DOE on October 31, 2016,] and [removed: was for $12.0] [added: approved on February 1, 2017, in the amount $11.3] million (APS's share [removed: of this amount] is [removed: $3.6 million), was submitted to the DOE on November 2, 2015.][added: $3.3 million).]
Amounts recovered in the lawsuit and settlement were recorded as adjustments to [added: a] regulatory liability and had no impact on [removed: current] [added: the amount of reported net] income.
On November 19, 2013, the D.C. Circuit found that the DOE did not conduct a legally adequate fee assessment and ordered the Secretary to notify Congress of his [removed: intent to suspend collecting annual fees for nuclear waste disposal from nuclear power plant operators, as he is required to do pursuant to the NWPA and the D.C. Circuit’s order.]
[added: It documents the staff’s evaluation of whether the DOE’s] research and development and performance confirmation programs, as well as other administrative controls and systems, meet applicable NRC requirements.
Waste Confidence [added: and Continued Storage] — On June 8, 2012, the D.C. Circuit issued its decision on a challenge by several states and environmental groups of the NRC’s rulemaking regarding temporary storage and permanent disposal of high level nuclear waste and spent nuclear fuel.
The D.C. Circuit found that the agency’s 2010 Waste Confidence Decision update constituted a major federal action, which, consistent with [removed: the National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”),] [added: NEPA,] requires either an environmental impact statement or a finding of no significant impact from the agency’s actions.
On September 6, 2012, the NRC Commissioners issued a directive to the NRC staff to proceed directly with development of a generic environmental impact statement to support an updated Waste Confidence [removed: Decision.]
[removed: The continued storage rule] [added: Renamed as the Continued Storage Rule, the NRC’s decision] adopted the findings of the GEIS regarding the environmental impacts of storing spent fuel at any reactor site after the reactor’s licensed period of operations.
Additionally, 4CA, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Pinnacle West, owns 7% of Units 4 and 5 following its acquisition of El Paso's interest in these units described below.
In connection with APS’s prior retail
On August 8, 2016, the Arizona Supreme Court issued its opinion in the SIB matter, and the Arizona Court of Appeals has now ordered supplemental briefing on how that SIB decision should affect the challenge to the Four Corners rate adjustment.
4CA purchased the El Paso interest on July 6, 2016.
On April 20, 2016, several environmental groups filed a lawsuit against OSM and other federal agencies in the District of Arizona in connection with their issuance of the approvals that extended the life of Four Corners and the adjacent mine.
The lawsuit alleges that these federal agencies violated both the Endangered Species Act ("ESA") and the National Environmental Policy Act ("NEPA") in providing the federal approvals necessary to extend operations at Four Corners and the adjacent Navajo Mine past July 6, 2016.
APS filed a motion to intervene in the proceedings, which was granted on August 3, 2016.
Briefing on the merits of this litigation is expected to extend through May 2017.
On September 15, 2016, NTEC, the company that owns the adjacent mine, filed a motion to intervene for the purpose of dismissing the lawsuit based on NTEC's tribal sovereign immunity.
Because the court has placed a stay on all litigation deadlines pending its decision regarding NTEC's motion to dismiss, the schedule for briefing and the anticipated timeline for completion of this litigation will likely be extended.
We cannot predict the outcome of this matter or its potential effect on Four Corners.
PacifiCorp owns Cholla Unit 4,
On January 13, 2017, EPA approved a final rule incorporating APS's compromise approach.
Once the final rule is published in the Federal Register, parties have 60 days to file a petition for review in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
APS cannot predict at this time whether such petitions will be filed or if they will be successful.
In addition, under the terms of an executive memorandum issued on January 20, 2017, this final rule will not be published in the Federal Register until after it has been reviewed by an appointee of the President.
We cannot predict when such review will occur and what may result from the additional review.
On April 13, 2016, Peabody Energy Corporation and certain affiliated entities filed a petition for relief under chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Missouri.
Under the Coal Supply Agreement, dated December 21, 2005, Peabody supplied coal to APS and PacifiCorp (collectively, the “Buyers”) for use at Cholla.
APS believes that the Coal Supply Agreement terminated automatically on April 13, 2016 as a result of Peabody's bankruptcy filing.
The Buyers filed a motion requesting that the Bankruptcy Court enter an order determining that the Buyers are authorized to enforce the termination provisions in the Coal Supply Agreement.
On May 13, 2016, Peabody filed a complaint against the Buyers in the bankruptcy court in which Peabody alleged that the Buyers breached the Coal Supply Agreement.
On January 27, 2017, the bankruptcy court approved a settlement between the parties, and on February 6, 2017 the parties executed an amendment to the Coal Supply Agreement that allows for continuation of the agreement with modified terms and conditions acceptable to the parties.
On February 13, 2017, the co-owners of the Navajo Plant voted not to pursue continued operation of the plant beyond December 2019, the expiration of the current lease term, and to pursue a new lease or lease extension with the Navajo Nation that would allow decommissioning activities to begin after December 2019 instead of later this year.
Various stakeholders including regulators, tribal representatives and others interested in the continued operation of the plant intend to meet to determine if an alternate solution can be reached that would permit continued operation of the plant beyond 2019.
We cannot predict whether any alternate solutions will be found that would be acceptable to all of the stakeholders and feasible to implement.
APS is currently
recovering depreciation and a return on the net book value of its interest in the Navajo Plant.
APS will seek continued recovery in rates for the book value of its remaining investment in the plant ($108 million as of December 31, 2016) plus a return on the net book value as well as other costs related to retirement and closure, which are still being assessed and which may be material.
We cannot predict whether APS would obtain such recovery.
On February 14, 2017, the ACC opened a docket titled "ACC Investigation Concerning the Future of the Navajo Generating Station" with the stated goal of engaging stakeholders and negotiating a sustainable pathway for the Navajo Plant to continue operating in some form after December 2019.
In addition, the settlement agreement provides APS with a method for submitting claims and getting recovery for costs incurred through December 31, 2016, which has been extended to December 31, 2019.
APS has submitted two claims pursuant to the terms of the August 18, 2014 settlement agreement, for two separate time periods during July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2015.
The DOE has approved and paid $53.9 million for these claims (APS’s share is $15.7 million).
The amounts recovered were primarily recorded as adjustments to a regulatory liability and had no impact on reported net income.
Payment for the claim is expected in the second quarter of 2017.
intent to suspend collecting annual fees for nuclear waste disposal from nuclear power plant operators, as he is required to do pursuant to the NWPA and the D.C. Circuit’s order.
Decision.
In June 2016, the D.C. Circuit issued its final decision, rejecting all remaining legal challenges to the Continued Storage Rule.
On August 8, 2016, the D.C. Circuit denied a petition for rehearing.
transaction for cost recovery purposes upon the closing of the transaction.
Completion of the purchase is subject to the receipt of certain regulatory approvals and is expected to occur in July 2016.
APS is negotiating a definitive purchase agreement with NTEC for the purchase of the 7% interest.
EPA, in its final regional haze rule for Four Corners, required the Four Corners’ owners to elect one of two emissions alternatives to apply to the plant.
On December 30, 2013, APS, on behalf of the co-owners, notified EPA that they chose the alternative BART compliance strategy requiring the permanent closure of Units 1, 2 and 3 by January 1, 2014 and installation and operation of SCR controls on Units 4 and 5 by July 31, 2018.
On December 30, 2013, APS retired Units 1, 2 and 3.
The Four Corners plant site is leased from the Navajo Nation and is also subject to an easement from the federal government.
The record of decision provided the authority for the Bureau of Indian Affairs to sign the lease amendments and rights-of-way renewals, which occurred in late July 2015.
On December 21, 2015, several environmental groups filed a notice of intent to sue with OSM and other federal agencies under the Endangered Species Act alleging that OSM's reliance on the Biological Opinion and Incidental Take Statement prepared in connection with the environmental review described above were not in accordance with applicable law.
We are monitoring this matter and will intervene if a lawsuit is filed.
In 2012, several environmental groups filed a lawsuit in federal district court against OSM challenging OSM’s 2012 approval of a permit revision which allowed for the expansion of mining operations into a new area of the mine that serves Four Corners ("Area IV North").
In April 2015, the court issued an order invalidating the permit revision, thereby prohibiting mining in Area IV North until OSM takes action to cure the defect in its permitting process identified by the court.
On December 29, 2015, OSM took action to cure the defect in its permitting process by issuing a revised environmental assessment and finding of no new significant impact, and reissued the permit.
This action is subject to possible judicial review.
The Cholla coal contract runs through 2024.
See "Environmental Matters - EPA Environmental Regulation - Regional Haze Rules - Navajo Plant" below for a discussion of potential future plans for the Navajo Plant.
costs incurred by Palo Verde during the period January 1, 2007 through June 30, 2011.
APS’s first claim made pursuant to the terms of the August 18, 2014 settlement agreement, which was for the period July 1, 2011 through June 30, 2014, was for $42.0 million (APS’s share of this amount was $12.2 million), and payment was received on June 1, 2015.
The second claim is presently being reviewed by DOE.
It documents the staff’s evaluation of whether the DOE’s
life of the facility, we are on track to meet the current site specific decommissioning costs for Palo Verde at the time the units are expected to be decommissioned.
Impact of Earthquake and Tsunami in Japan on Nuclear Energy Industry — On March 11, 2011, an earthquake measuring 9.0 on the Richter Scale occurred off the coast of Japan causing a series of seven tsunamis.
As a result, the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station experienced severe damage.
Following the earthquake and tsunamis, the NRC established a task force to conduct a systematic and methodical review of NRC processes and regulations to determine whether the agency should make additional improvements to its regulatory system.
On March 12, 2012, the NRC issued the first regulatory requirements based on the recommendations of the Near Term Task Force.
With respect to Palo Verde, the NRC issued two orders requiring safety enhancements regarding: (1) mitigation strategies to respond to extreme natural events resulting in the loss of power at the plant; and (2) enhancement of spent fuel pool instrumentation.
The NRC has issued a number of guidance documents regarding implementation of these requirements.
Palo Verde has met the NRC’s imposed deadlines for installation of equipment to address these requirements, but has minor additional work to perform in 2016.
Palo Verde has spent approximately $125 million on capital enhancements as of December 31, 2015 (APS’s share is 29.1%).
APS completed a competitive solicitation process in which the Ocotillo project was evaluated against other alternatives.
Consistent with the independent monitor’s report, the Ocotillo project was selected as the best alternative.
APS must finalize the permitting process before construction begins.
To date, APS has begun operation of 170 MW of utility scale solar through its AZ Sun Program, discussed below.
In December 2014, the ACC voted that it had no objection to APS implementing a 10 MWdc (approximately 8.5 MWac) residential rooftop program.
The first stage of the residential rooftop solar program, called the "Solar Partner Program", is to be 8 MW followed by a 2 MW second stage that will only be deployed if coupled with distributed storage.
Under this program, APS will own, operate and maintain approximately 1,500 residential systems.
The program will target specific distribution feeders in an effort to maximize potential system benefits, while employing multiple "use cases" that will lead to a better understanding of the byproducts stemming from the multitude of complex technical interactions occurring as distributed energy resources are employed on the APS grid.
| Day-Ahead Call Option Agreement | | Summer seasons through summer 2016 | | 150 | |
Excluding certain contractual rights to call on additional capacity on short notice, which APS may use in the event of unusual weather or unplanned outages, the 2015 reserve margin was 21%.
APS anticipates the reserve margin for 2016 will be approximately 24%.
An excerpt. Shown here: 40 of 111 rewritten, 40 of 135 added and 40 of 108 removed. The counts are complete. For every sentence, read Item 1. BUSINESS in the FY2016 filing and the FY2015 filing.
Item 3. LEGAL PROCEEDINGS
1 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 2 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
See Note 10 for information regarding environmental [removed: matters, Superfund–related matters,] matters [removed: related to a September 2011 power outage] and [removed: a New Mexico tax matter.][added: Superfund–related matters.]
Cover and table of contents
35 rewritten, 9 added, 8 removed, 136 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
For the fiscal year ended December 31, [removed: 2015][added: 2016]
| ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY | | $0 as of June 30, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] |
The number of shares outstanding of each registrant’s common stock as of February [removed: 12, 2016][added: 17, 2017]
| PINNACLE WEST CAPITAL CORPORATION | | [removed: 111,004,916] [added: 111,340,169] shares |
Portions of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation’s definitive Proxy Statement relating to its Annual Meeting of Shareholders to be held on May [removed: 18, 2016] [added: 17, 2017] are incorporated by reference into Part III hereof.
| [GLOSSARY OF NAMES AND TECHNICAL [removed: TERMS](#s71D5A4B8C6415B71B3FD23E683D1B862)] [added: TERMS](#s56310DD7915B597082DEBD756B2806C3)] | | [removed: [ii](#s71D5A4B8C6415B71B3FD23E683D1B862)] [added: [ii](#s56310DD7915B597082DEBD756B2806C3)] |
| [FORWARD-LOOKING [removed: STATEMENTS](#s6809D4238B5E565388DA913552DB12E6)] [added: STATEMENTS](#s0ED74F446B075731AA099FE683CE2506)] | | [removed: [2](#s6809D4238B5E565388DA913552DB12E6)] [added: [2](#s0ED74F446B075731AA099FE683CE2506)] |
| [Item [removed: 1.](#sFDC830C5D1715174A4FAD505F88A33E2)] [added: 1.](#s7AF66D1712A45B2A8886FFF4E69B0297)] | [removed: [Business](#sFDC830C5D1715174A4FAD505F88A33E2)] [added: [Business](#s7AF66D1712A45B2A8886FFF4E69B0297)] | [removed: [3](#sFDC830C5D1715174A4FAD505F88A33E2)] [added: [3](#s7AF66D1712A45B2A8886FFF4E69B0297)] |
| [Item [removed: 1A.](#s6346E71DBB48545B9AE53CFD17B816FA)] [added: 1A.](#s80BAB86109755030AA04B620DBCC712D)] | [Risk [removed: Factors](#s6346E71DBB48545B9AE53CFD17B816FA)] [added: Factors](#s80BAB86109755030AA04B620DBCC712D)] | [removed: [27](#s6346E71DBB48545B9AE53CFD17B816FA)] [added: [29](#s80BAB86109755030AA04B620DBCC712D)] |
| [Item [removed: 1B.](#s312123A8D6AE5B6D98EECD2FD948D5B3)] [added: 1B.](#s20E78168CB0D52A58E4EE53F5401B6C8)] | [Unresolved Staff [removed: Comments](#s312123A8D6AE5B6D98EECD2FD948D5B3)] [added: Comments](#s20E78168CB0D52A58E4EE53F5401B6C8)] | [removed: [38](#s312123A8D6AE5B6D98EECD2FD948D5B3)] [added: [41](#s20E78168CB0D52A58E4EE53F5401B6C8)] |
| [Item [removed: 2.](#sC5222C6FE2A554D9AE49F841C5C1FF1A)] [added: 2.](#s0A7C4276EDFF5F439F791AD78357909D)] | [removed: [Properties](#sC5222C6FE2A554D9AE49F841C5C1FF1A)] [added: [Properties](#s0A7C4276EDFF5F439F791AD78357909D)] | [removed: [39](#sC5222C6FE2A554D9AE49F841C5C1FF1A)] [added: [42](#s0A7C4276EDFF5F439F791AD78357909D)] |
| [Item [removed: 3.](#s16C38C5AAF605CC68DF75AD0FEC6D9A5)] [added: 3.](#sB7443A949CAE5311BF575140EC320A0C)] | [Legal [removed: Proceedings](#s16C38C5AAF605CC68DF75AD0FEC6D9A5)] [added: Proceedings](#sB7443A949CAE5311BF575140EC320A0C)] | [removed: [42](#s16C38C5AAF605CC68DF75AD0FEC6D9A5)] [added: [45](#sB7443A949CAE5311BF575140EC320A0C)] |
| [Item [removed: 4.](#s4FAF4F9824CC568780B9F5AD1DFBDB85)] [added: 4.](#s8C3405B8EA2754B089203E9D1E2C3CB7)] | [Mine Safety [removed: Disclosures](#s4FAF4F9824CC568780B9F5AD1DFBDB85)] [added: Disclosures](#s8C3405B8EA2754B089203E9D1E2C3CB7)] | [removed: [42](#s4FAF4F9824CC568780B9F5AD1DFBDB85)] [added: [45](#s8C3405B8EA2754B089203E9D1E2C3CB7)] |
| [Executive Officers of Pinnacle [removed: West](#s439F5BFE50815BF9A59780B084D97F1A)] [added: West](#s65BAC96708065FA38B487E6DA52602B4)] | | [removed: [43](#s439F5BFE50815BF9A59780B084D97F1A)] [added: [46](#s65BAC96708065FA38B487E6DA52602B4)] |
| [Item [removed: 5.](#s1E4257A6DD2559738E2B82E792F5953E)] [added: 5.](#s7DC61FFF378159DD8C0843930735A816)] | [Market for Registrants’ Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases of Equity [removed: Securities](#s1E4257A6DD2559738E2B82E792F5953E)] [added: Securities](#s7DC61FFF378159DD8C0843930735A816)] | [removed: [44](#s1E4257A6DD2559738E2B82E792F5953E)] [added: [47](#s7DC61FFF378159DD8C0843930735A816)] |
| [Item [removed: 6.](#s2567F3528A5055E5A193C65A041764E3)] [added: 6.](#s8F52CCB66263587A8C9BBD2BFE88BACC)] | [Selected Financial [removed: Data](#s2567F3528A5055E5A193C65A041764E3)] [added: Data](#s8F52CCB66263587A8C9BBD2BFE88BACC)] | [removed: [46](#s2567F3528A5055E5A193C65A041764E3)] [added: [48](#s8F52CCB66263587A8C9BBD2BFE88BACC)] |
| [Item [removed: 7.](#sC86D194A2B1B5AB888A4FC84945EBCD1)] [added: 7.](#s5DAE1D44DB4B57E4A36FC3F879CC669B)] | [Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of [removed: Operations](#sC86D194A2B1B5AB888A4FC84945EBCD1)] [added: Operations](#s5DAE1D44DB4B57E4A36FC3F879CC669B)] | [removed: [48](#sC86D194A2B1B5AB888A4FC84945EBCD1)] [added: [50](#s5DAE1D44DB4B57E4A36FC3F879CC669B)] |
| [Item [removed: 7A.](#sEA65CF3917EF578C83E98B69B1B715AC)] [added: 7A.](#s77CE437588A95C16A5DC5F61DD023C40)] | [Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market [removed: Risk](#sEA65CF3917EF578C83E98B69B1B715AC)] [added: Risk](#s77CE437588A95C16A5DC5F61DD023C40)] | [removed: [72](#sEA65CF3917EF578C83E98B69B1B715AC)] [added: [77](#s77CE437588A95C16A5DC5F61DD023C40)] |
| [Item [removed: 8.](#sDC19AA73B8FD5F58979EA8D2D0D54AB0)] [added: 8.](#sCAD4E6432613528B80A03C0FB4E22D86)] | [Financial Statements and Supplementary [removed: Data](#sDC19AA73B8FD5F58979EA8D2D0D54AB0)] [added: Data](#sCAD4E6432613528B80A03C0FB4E22D86)] | [removed: [73](#sDC19AA73B8FD5F58979EA8D2D0D54AB0)] [added: [78](#sCAD4E6432613528B80A03C0FB4E22D86)] |
| | [Pinnacle West Financial [removed: Statements](#s11F069E7BFC3528FA2B8AE5EB37292E6)] [added: Statements](#sAFD3F0D02D285BDBB997D6E8730B3433)] | [removed: [77](#s11F069E7BFC3528FA2B8AE5EB37292E6)] [added: [82](#sAFD3F0D02D285BDBB997D6E8730B3433)] |
| | [APS Financial [removed: Statements](#s37A6876BC2135AC9812CA727F4D287EB)] [added: Statements](#s5AD964A4B9A85B1ABC324DE5E7BB3430)] | [removed: [86](#s37A6876BC2135AC9812CA727F4D287EB)] [added: [91](#s5AD964A4B9A85B1ABC324DE5E7BB3430)] |
| | [Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial [removed: Statements](#sD732FC25C9D35AC79E2FCBE13601CC5A)] [added: Statements](#sEA575E78E1BF5B439FCA65C38798699A)] | [removed: [92](#sD732FC25C9D35AC79E2FCBE13601CC5A)] [added: [97](#sEA575E78E1BF5B439FCA65C38798699A)] |
| [Item [removed: 9.](#s3EF6149B19DF5401BD4F5853E36F089A)] [added: 9.](#s48DCF409EC3E594A9EE2AC11B595F59C)] | [Changes in and Disagreements with Accountants on Accounting and Financial [removed: Disclosure](#s3EF6149B19DF5401BD4F5853E36F089A)] [added: Disclosure](#s48DCF409EC3E594A9EE2AC11B595F59C)] | [removed: [162](#s3EF6149B19DF5401BD4F5853E36F089A)] [added: [175](#s48DCF409EC3E594A9EE2AC11B595F59C)] |
| [Item [removed: 9A.](#s98FF7F748E0D5D78B2E1F7A855E4015C)] [added: 9A.](#sD6ABBFF4AEC253E196AAFB5A31C2CBFC)] | [Controls and [removed: Procedures](#s3EF6149B19DF5401BD4F5853E36F089A)] [added: Procedures](#s48DCF409EC3E594A9EE2AC11B595F59C)] | [removed: [162](#s98FF7F748E0D5D78B2E1F7A855E4015C)] [added: [175](#sD6ABBFF4AEC253E196AAFB5A31C2CBFC)] |
| [Item [removed: 9B.](#sCC430066CA5F508B98C830DA0B7E03DE)] [added: 9B.](#s02B8581D781753528A3389FA2D0E5A5C)] | [Other [removed: Information](#sCC430066CA5F508B98C830DA0B7E03DE)] [added: Information](#s02B8581D781753528A3389FA2D0E5A5C)] | [removed: [163](#sCC430066CA5F508B98C830DA0B7E03DE)] [added: [176](#s02B8581D781753528A3389FA2D0E5A5C)] |
| [Item [removed: 10.](#s1EBE803AB0785702805D8E644410530A)] [added: 10.](#s152E94B2F1675336833FF7FF9F743D22)] | [Directors, Executive Officers and Corporate Governance of Pinnacle [removed: West](#s1EBE803AB0785702805D8E644410530A)] [added: West](#s152E94B2F1675336833FF7FF9F743D22)] | [removed: [163](#s1EBE803AB0785702805D8E644410530A)] [added: [176](#s152E94B2F1675336833FF7FF9F743D22)] |
| [Item [removed: 11.](#sE54C00639E4B5B3193278E7824504C43)] [added: 11.](#s0F67A3B3E46A5806929E58F03529C965)] | [Executive [removed: Compensation](#sE54C00639E4B5B3193278E7824504C43)] [added: Compensation](#s0F67A3B3E46A5806929E58F03529C965)] | [removed: [163](#sE54C00639E4B5B3193278E7824504C43)] [added: [176](#s0F67A3B3E46A5806929E58F03529C965)] |
| [Item [removed: 12.](#s365A430E7852565EA59BF499B6B36D62)] [added: 12.](#s7D8C63C6247E57BA9CEBC98A24E4936B)] | [Security Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management and Related Stockholder [removed: Matters](#s365A430E7852565EA59BF499B6B36D62)] [added: Matters](#s7D8C63C6247E57BA9CEBC98A24E4936B)] | [removed: [163](#s365A430E7852565EA59BF499B6B36D62)] [added: [176](#s7D8C63C6247E57BA9CEBC98A24E4936B)] |
| [Item [removed: 13.](#sFD3FBA3DEBF85CEB8871EE9BA63BE663)] [added: 13.](#s6C1DB8943C525774BC28425DE3AF847B)] | [Certain Relationships and Related Transactions, and Director [removed: Independence](#sFD3FBA3DEBF85CEB8871EE9BA63BE663)] [added: Independence](#s6C1DB8943C525774BC28425DE3AF847B)] | [removed: [164](#sFD3FBA3DEBF85CEB8871EE9BA63BE663)] [added: [176](#s6C1DB8943C525774BC28425DE3AF847B)] |
| [Item [removed: 14.](#s2DF884C2F21E5178BA50B9EF7BBA9B0D)] [added: 14.](#s6534300F5843542CBEC0B67694362511)] | [Principal Accountant Fees and [removed: Services](#s2DF884C2F21E5178BA50B9EF7BBA9B0D)] [added: Services](#s6534300F5843542CBEC0B67694362511)] | [removed: [165](#s2DF884C2F21E5178BA50B9EF7BBA9B0D)] [added: [177](#s6534300F5843542CBEC0B67694362511)] |
| [Item [removed: 15.](#s635E74AE1C6451529F116D5B740FF851)] [added: 15.](#sB506B718AE305059BEABEC9563640BAB)] | [Exhibits and Financial Statement [removed: Schedules](#s635E74AE1C6451529F116D5B740FF851)] [added: Schedules](#sB506B718AE305059BEABEC9563640BAB)] | [removed: [166](#s635E74AE1C6451529F116D5B740FF851)] [added: [178](#sB506B718AE305059BEABEC9563640BAB)] |
These forward-looking statements are often identified by words such as “estimate,” “predict,” “may,” “believe,” “plan,” “expect,” “require,” “intend,” [removed: “assume”] [added: “assume,” “project”] and similar words.
| • | variations in demand for electricity, including those due to weather, [added: seasonality,] the general economy, customer and sales growth (or decline), and the effects of energy conservation measures and distributed generation; |
| • | new [removed: legislation or] [added: legislation, ballot initiatives and] regulation, including those relating to environmental requirements, [added: regulatory policy,] nuclear plant operations and potential deregulation of retail electric markets; |
| • | [removed: environmental] [added: environmental, economic] and other concerns surrounding coal-fired generation, including regulation of greenhouse gas emissions; |
10-K 1 pnw2016123110-k.htm 10-K
| PINNACLE WEST CAPITAL CORPORATION | | $8,961,361,256 as of June 30, 2016 |
| [PART I](#sC328284DA9175B709FAD808D6AC081DB) | | [3](#sC328284DA9175B709FAD808D6AC081DB) |
| [PART II](#sE2405F070D1954F49E2E43B10475873A) | | [47](#sE2405F070D1954F49E2E43B10475873A) |
| [PART III](#s1B5E2F818F8E558C88BD09E3395E839C) | | [176](#s1B5E2F818F8E558C88BD09E3395E839C) |
| [PART IV](#s0F9F386C527354AE8C394F3035FE29A4) | | [178](#s0F9F386C527354AE8C394F3035FE29A4) |
| [SIGNATURES](#sD3293D58BBF351248AFB183D45788A99) | | [198](#sD3293D58BBF351248AFB183D45788A99) |
| 4CA | 4C Acquisition, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Pinnacle West |
| ASU | Accounting Standards Update |
10-K 1 pnw2015123110-k.htm 10-K
| PINNACLE WEST CAPITAL CORPORATION | | $6,271,269,171 as of June 30, 2015 |
| [PART I](#s835C4537B2105DBC916C415DCDB9A4F9) | | [3](#s835C4537B2105DBC916C415DCDB9A4F9) |
| [PART II](#s3E942AC666915996B2B7203999E221AF) | | [44](#s3E942AC666915996B2B7203999E221AF) |
| [PART III](#s86E3A2D3A80750FF85FC05CD01BD3AF2) | | [163](#s86E3A2D3A80750FF85FC05CD01BD3AF2) |
| [PART IV](#s6CA72D3573F951E7889771870B36F735) | | [166](#s6CA72D3573F951E7889771870B36F735) |
| [SIGNATURES](#s488CAA48694B5DCEBDFDDCE58017FAAB) | | [186](#s488CAA48694B5DCEBDFDDCE58017FAAB) |
| SIB | System Improvement Benefits |
Item 1B. UNRESOLVED STAFF COMMENTS
1 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 0 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Neither Pinnacle West nor APS has received written comments regarding its periodic or current reports from the SEC staff that were issued 180 days or more preceding the end of its [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] fiscal year and that remain unresolved.
Item 2. PROPERTIES
34 rewritten, 10 added, 8 removed, 63 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
| Cholla [added: 1,3] (d) | | 2 | | | | | Coal | | Base Load | | 387 | |
| Saguaro [removed: 1, 2] | | [removed: 2] [added: 3] | | | | | [removed: Gas/Oil] [added: Gas] | | Peaking | | [removed: 110] [added: 189] | |
| [removed: Saguaro] [added: Yucca 1, 2,] 3 | | [removed: 1] [added: 3] | | | | | Gas | | Peaking | | [removed: 79] [added: 93] | |
| Hyder [added: I] | | 1 | | | | | Solar | | As Available | | 16 | |
| APS Owned Distributed Energy | | | | | | | Solar | | As Available | | [removed: 15] [added: 25] | |
| Total Solar | | | | | | | | | | | [removed: 189] [added: 239] | |
| Total Capacity | | | | | | | | | | | [removed: 6,186] [added: 6,236] | |
| (c) | The other participants are Salt River Project (10%), Public Service Company of New Mexico (13%), Tucson Electric Power Company (7%) and [removed: El Paso] [added: 4CA] (7%). The plant is operated by APS. |
| (e) | The other participants are Salt River Project [removed: (21.7%),] [added: (42.9%),] Nevada Power Company (11.3%), the United States Government [removed: (24.3%),] [added: (24.3%) and] Tucson Electric Power Company [removed: (7.5%) and Los Angeles Department of Water & Power (21.2%).] [added: (7.5%).] The plant is operated by Salt River Project. [added: In July 2016, Salt River Project purchased Los Angeles Department of Water & Power's share in this plant (21.2%).] |
APS’s transmission facilities consist of approximately [removed: 6,070] [added: 6,140] pole miles of overhead lines and approximately 49 miles of underground lines, [removed: 5,847] [added: 5,917] miles of which are located in Arizona.
APS’s distribution facilities consist of approximately [removed: 11,077] [added: 11,144] miles of overhead lines and approximately [removed: 18,071] [added: 21,128] miles of underground primary cable, all of which are located in Arizona.
APS distribution facilities reflect an actual net gain of [removed: 169] [added: 3,124] miles in [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
The following table shows APS’s jointly-owned interests in those transmission facilities recorded on the Consolidated Balance Sheets at December 31, [removed: 2015:][added: 2016:]
| Morgan — Pinnacle Peak System | [removed: 64.6] [added: 65.2] | % |
| Palo Verde — [removed: Estrella] [added: Rudd] 500kV System | 50.0 | % |
| ANPP 500kV System | [removed: 33.4] [added: 33.6] | % |
| Navajo Southern System | [removed: 22.7] [added: 22.5] | % |
| Four Corners Switchyards | [removed: 49.8] [added: 51.3] | % |
| Palo Verde — Yuma 500kV System | [removed: 19.3] [added: 19.0] | % |
| Palo Verde — Morgan System | [removed: 87.7] [added: 85.8] | % |
In APS’s [removed: 2015] [added: 2017] plan, APS projects it will develop [removed: 275] [added: 52] miles of new [added: transmission] lines over the next ten years.
The Palo Verde to Morgan System includes Palo Verde-Delaney-Sun [removed: Valley-Morgan.][added: Valley-Morgan-Pinnacle Peak.]
The first [removed: phase,] [added: three phases,] Morgan to Pinnacle Peak 500kV, [removed: is] [added: Palo Verde to Delaney 500kV, and Delaney to Sun Valley 500kV are] currently in-service.
The fourth phase, Morgan to Sun Valley 500kV, has [removed: been permitted] [added: started construction] and is [removed: in final design and development.][added: expected to be energized by May 2018.]
Two such projects, which [removed: are] [added: have been completed and were] included in [removed: APS’s 2015] [added: previous APS] transmission [removed: plan,] [added: plans,] are the Delaney to Palo Verde line and the North Gila to Hassayampa line, both of which [removed: are intended to] support the transmission of renewable energy to Phoenix and California.
The North Gila to Hassayampa line went into service in May [removed: 2015.][added: 2015 and the Delaney to Palo Verde line went into service in May 2016.]
As required by the Physical Security Reliability Standard, APS determined its critical transmission stations and substations and associated primary control centers that [removed: will be] [added: were] required to comply with the standard by October 2, 2015.
However, as contemplated under CIP-014-2, this verification [removed: has] triggered additional requirements and obligations within the Physical Security Reliability [removed: Standard that are not yet due to be completed.][added: Standard.]
These remaining obligations, which consist of a risk evaluation and development and verification of a physical security plan, [added: were largely completed in 2016 and the remaining activities] are [removed: due] [added: projected] to be completed [removed: by the end] [added: in] the [removed: third quarter] [added: second and fourth quarters] of [removed: 2016.][added: 2017.]
NERC Critical Infrastructure Protection [removed: Requirements.][added: Reliability Standards.]
In 2014, APS initiated a comprehensive project to ensure compliance with Version 5 of NERC's Critical Infrastructure Protection [removed: Requirements] [added: Reliability Standards] (CIP [removed: V.5)] [added: V.5),] which will become effective [removed: April 1, 2016.][added: pursuant to various implementation dates through 2018.]
APS will be incurring incremental capital expenditures through [removed: 2017] [added: 2018 to meet further upcoming compliance deadlines] associated with [removed: the] CIP [removed: V.5 compliance implementation project estimated to be approximately $52 million.][added: V.5.]
Certain portions of [removed: the] [added: our] transmission lines [removed: that carry power from several of our power plants] are located on Indian lands pursuant to rights-of-way that are effective for specified periods.
In recent negotiations, certain of the affected Indian tribes have [added: required payments substantially in excess of amounts that we have paid in the past for such rights-of-way.]
APS
| Red Rock | | 1 | | | | | Solar | | As Available | | 40 | |
4CA
4CA, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Pinnacle West, purchased El Paso's 7% interest in Units 4 and 5 of Four Corners on July 6, 2016.
See "Areas of Business Focus - Operational Performance, Reliability and Recent Developments - Four Corners - Asset Purchase Agreement and Coal Supply Matters" in Item 7 for additional information about 4CA's interest in Four Corners.
APS completed a significant portion of its compliance implementation activities in June 2016, meeting an initial compliance date of July 1, 2016.
Total expenditures are estimated to be approximately $52 million.
APS, on behalf of the Four Corners participants, negotiated amendments to the facility lease with the Navajo Nation, which extends the Four Corners leasehold interest from 2016 to 2041.
See "Areas of Business Focus - Operational Performance, Reliability and Recent Developments - Four Corners - Lease Extension" in Item 7 for additional information about the Four Corners right-of-way and lease matters.
See "Navajo Plant" in Note 3 for information regarding future plans for the Navajo Plant.
| Yucca 1, 2, 3 | | 3 | | | | | Gas/Oil | | Peaking | | 93 | |
The second
and third phases, Delaney to Palo Verde 500kV and Delaney to Sun Valley 500kV, are under construction and are expected to be energized by May 2016.
In March, 2011, the Navajo Nation Council signed a resolution approving a 25-year extension to the existing Four Corners lease term and providing Navajo Nation consent to renewal of the related rights-of-way.
The effectiveness of the lease amendment also required the approval of the DOI, as did the related federal rights-of-way grant.
A federal environmental review was undertaken as part of the DOI review process, and culminated in the issuance by DOI of a record of decision on July 17, 2015.
The record of decision provides the authority for the Bureau of Indian Affairs to sign the lease amendments and rights-of-way renewals, which occurred in late July 2015.
required payments substantially in excess of amounts that we have paid in the past for such rights-of-way.
Item 4. MINE SAFETY DISCLOSURES
14 rewritten, 5 added, 5 removed, 19 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
The executive officers, their ages at February [removed: 19, 2016,] [added: 24, 2017,] current positions and principal occupations for the past five years are as follows:
| Donald E. Brandt | | [removed: 61] [added: 62] | | Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer of Pinnacle West; Chairman of the Board of APS | | 2009-Present |
| [removed: Robert S. Bement] | | [removed: 60] | | Senior Vice President, Site Operations, PVNGS, of APS | | [removed: 2011-Present] [added: 2011-2016] |
| Denise R. Danner | | [removed: 60] [added: 61] | | Vice President, Controller and Chief Accounting Officer of Pinnacle West; Chief Accounting Officer of APS | | 2010-Present |
| [removed: Patrick Dinkel] [added: Daniel T. Froetscher] | | [removed: 52] [added: 55] | | [added: Senior] Vice President, [removed: Transmission and] [added: Transmission,] Distribution [removed: Operations] [added: & Customers] of APS | | 2014-Present |
| | | | | Vice President, [removed: Resource Management] [added: Human Resources] of APS | | [removed: 2012-2014] [added: 2014-2016] |
| [removed: Randall K. Edington] [added: Robert S. Bement] | | [removed: 62] [added: 61] | | Executive Vice President and Chief Nuclear Officer, PVNGS, of APS | | [removed: 2007-Present] [added: 2016-Present] |
| David P. Falck | | [removed: 62] [added: 63] | | Executive Vice President and General Counsel of Pinnacle West and APS | | 2009-Present |
| [removed: Daniel T. Froetscher] [added: Jeffrey B. Guldner] | | [removed: 54] [added: 51] | | Senior Vice President, [removed: Transmission, Distribution & Customers] [added: Public Policy] of APS | | 2014-Present |
| Barbara M. Gomez [added: (b)] | | [removed: 61] [added: 62] | | [added: Senior] Vice President, Human Resources of APS | | [removed: 2014-Present] [added: 2016-Present] |
| James R. Hatfield | | [removed: 58] [added: 59] | | Executive Vice President of Pinnacle West and APS | | 2012-Present |
| John S. Hatfield | | [removed: 50] [added: 51] | | Vice President, Communications of APS | | 2010-Present |
| [added: Mark A. Schiavoni] | | [added: 61] | | [added: Executive] Vice President and Chief [removed: Customer] [added: Operating] Officer of APS | | [removed: 2007-2014] [added: 2014-Present] |
| Lee R. Nickloy | | [removed: 49] [added: 50] | | Vice President and Treasurer of Pinnacle West and APS | | 2010-Present |
| Randall K. Edington (a) | | 63 | | Advisor to the CEO of APS | | 2016-Present |
| | | | | Executive Vice President of APS | | 2007-Present |
| | | | | Chief Nuclear Officer, PVNGS, of APS | | 2007-2016 |
| (a) | Randall K. Edington is retiring from APS on March 22, 2017. |
| (b) | Barbara M. Gomez is retiring from APS in July 2017. |
| | | | | Vice President, Power Marketing, Resource Planning and Acquisition of APS | | 2011-2012 |
| | | | | Vice President, Power Marketing and Resource Planning of APS | | 2010-2011 |
| Jeffrey B. Guldner | | 50 | | Senior Vice President, Public Policy of APS | | 2014-Present |
| Tammy D. McLeod | | 54 | | Vice President, Resource Management of APS | | 2014-Present |
| Mark A. Schiavoni | | 60 | | Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of APS | | 2014-Present |
Item 5. MARKET FOR REGISTRANTS’ COMMON EQUITY, RELATED
9 rewritten, 4 added, 12 removed, 16 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
At the close of business on February [removed: 12, 2016,] [added: 17, 2017,] Pinnacle West’s common stock was held of record by approximately [removed: 20,570] [added: 19,581] shareholders.
| [removed: 2014] [added: 2016] | | High | | | | Low | | | | Close | | | | Per Share | | |
The chart below sets forth the dividends paid on APS’s common stock for each of the four quarters for [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014.][added: 2015.]
| Quarter | | [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] | | | | [removed: 2014] [added: 2015] | | |
| 1st Quarter | | $ | [removed: 65,800] [added: 69,400] | | | $ | [removed: 62,500] [added: 65,800] | |
| 2nd Quarter | | [removed: 65,900] [added: 69,500] | | | | [removed: 62,600] [added: 65,900] | | |
| 3rd Quarter | | [removed: 65,900] [added: 69,500] | | | | [removed: 62,700] [added: 65,900] | | |
| 4th Quarter | | [removed: 69,300] [added: 72,900] | | | | [removed: 65,800] [added: 69,300] | | |
As of December 31, [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] APS did not have any outstanding preferred stock.
| 1st Quarter | | $ | 75.15 | | | $ | 62.51 | | | $ | 75.07 | | | $ | 0.625 | |
| 2nd Quarter | | 81.08 | | | | 70.11 | | | | 81.06 | | | | 0.625 | | |
| 3rd Quarter | | 82.78 | | | | 73.94 | | | | 75.99 | | | | 0.625 | | |
| 4th Quarter | | 78.97 | | | | 70.86 | | | | 78.03 | | | | 0.655 | | |
| 1st Quarter | | $ | 55.99 | | | $ | 51.15 | | | $ | 54.66 | | | $ | 0.5675 | |
| 2nd Quarter | | 58.06 | | | | 53.71 | | | | 57.84 | | | | 0.5675 | | |
| 3rd Quarter | | 57.95 | | | | 52.13 | | | | 54.64 | | | | 0.5675 | | |
| 4th Quarter | | 71.11 | | | | 54.59 | | | | 68.31 | | | | 0.595 | | |
Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities
The following table contains information about our purchases of our common stock during the fourth quarter of 2015.
| Period | | Total Number of Shares Purchased (1) | | | Average Price Paid per Share | | | | Total Number of Shares Purchased as Part of Publicly Announced Plans or Programs | | | Maximum Number of Shares that May Yet Be Purchased Under the Plans or Programs | |
| October 1 – October 31, 2015 | | 61,471 | | | $ | 65.74 | | | — | | | — | |
| November 1 – November 30, 2015 | | — | | | — | | | | — | | | — | |
| December 1 – December 31, 2015 | | — | | | — | | | | — | | | — | |
| Total | | 61,471 | | | $ | 65.74 | | | — | | | — | |
| (1) | Represents shares of common stock withheld by Pinnacle West to satisfy tax withholding obligations upon the vesting of performance shares. |
Item 6. SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
42 rewritten, 0 added, 4 removed, 12 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
The selected data presented below as of and for the years ended December 31, [added: 2016,] 2015, 2014, [removed: 2013, 2012] [added: 2013] and [removed: 2011] [added: 2012] are derived from the Consolidated Financial Statements.
| | | [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] | | | | [removed: 2014] [added: 2015] | | | | [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] | | | | [removed: 2012] [added: 2013] | | | | [removed: 2011] [added: 2012] | | |
| Operating revenues | | $ | [removed: 3,495,443] [added: 3,498,682] | | | $ | [removed: 3,491,632] [added: 3,495,443] | | | $ | [removed: 3,454,628] [added: 3,491,632] | | | $ | [removed: 3,301,804] [added: 3,454,628] | | | $ | [removed: 3,241,379] [added: 3,301,804] | |
| Income from continuing operations | | $ | [removed: 456,190] [added: 461,527] | | | $ | [removed: 423,696] [added: 456,190] | | | $ | [removed: 439,966] [added: 423,696] | | | $ | [removed: 418,993] [added: 439,966] | | | $ | [removed: 355,634] [added: 418,993] | |
| [removed: Income (loss)] [added: Loss] from discontinued operations – net of income taxes | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | [removed: (5,829] [added: —] | | [removed: )] | | [removed: 11,306] [added: (5,829] | | [added: )] |
| Net income | | [removed: 456,190] [added: 461,527] | | | | [removed: 423,696] [added: 456,190] | | | | [removed: 439,966] [added: 423,696] | | | | [removed: 413,164] [added: 439,966] | | | | [removed: 366,940] [added: 413,164] | | |
| Less: Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests | | [removed: 18,933] [added: 19,493] | | | | [removed: 26,101] [added: 18,933] | | | | [removed: 33,892] [added: 26,101] | | | | [removed: 31,622] [added: 33,892] | | | | [removed: 27,467] [added: 31,622] | | |
| Net income attributable to common shareholders | | $ | [removed: 437,257] [added: 442,034] | | | $ | [removed: 397,595] [added: 437,257] | | | $ | [removed: 406,074] [added: 397,595] | | | $ | [removed: 381,542] [added: 406,074] | | | $ | [removed: 339,473] [added: 381,542] | |
| Book value per share – year-end | | $ | [removed: 41.30] [added: 43.14] | | | $ | [removed: 39.50] [added: 41.30] | | | $ | [removed: 38.07] [added: 39.50] | | | $ | [removed: 36.20] [added: 38.07] | | | $ | [removed: 34.98] [added: 36.20] | |
| Continuing operations attributable to common shareholders – basic | | $ | [removed: 3.94] [added: 3.97] | | | $ | [removed: 3.59] [added: 3.94] | | | $ | [removed: 3.69] [added: 3.59] | | | $ | [removed: 3.54] [added: 3.69] | | | $ | [removed: 3.01] [added: 3.54] | |
| Net income attributable to common shareholders – basic | | $ | [removed: 3.94] [added: 3.97] | | | $ | [removed: 3.59] [added: 3.94] | | | $ | [removed: 3.69] [added: 3.59] | | | $ | [removed: 3.48] [added: 3.69] | | | $ | [removed: 3.11] [added: 3.48] | |
| Continuing operations attributable to common shareholders – diluted | | $ | [removed: 3.92] [added: 3.95] | | | $ | [removed: 3.58] [added: 3.92] | | | $ | [removed: 3.66] [added: 3.58] | | | $ | [removed: 3.50] [added: 3.66] | | | $ | [removed: 2.99] [added: 3.50] | |
| Net income attributable to common shareholders – diluted | | $ | [removed: 3.92] [added: 3.95] | | | $ | [removed: 3.58] [added: 3.92] | | | $ | [removed: 3.66] [added: 3.58] | | | $ | [removed: 3.45] [added: 3.66] | | | $ | [removed: 3.09] [added: 3.45] | |
| Dividends declared per share | | $ | [removed: 2.44] [added: 2.56] | | | $ | [removed: 2.33] [added: 2.44] | | | $ | [removed: 2.23] [added: 2.33] | | | $ | [removed: 2.67] [added: 2.23] | | | $ | [removed: 2.10] [added: 2.67] | |
| Weighted-average common shares outstanding – basic | | [removed: 111,025,944] [added: 111,408,729] | | | | [removed: 110,626,101] [added: 111,025,944] | | | | [removed: 109,984,160] [added: 110,626,101] | | | | [removed: 109,510,296] [added: 109,984,160] | | | | [removed: 109,052,840] [added: 109,510,296] | | |
| Weighted-average common shares outstanding – diluted | | [removed: 111,552,130] [added: 112,046,043] | | | | [removed: 111,178,141] [added: 111,552,130] | | | | [removed: 110,805,943] [added: 111,178,141] | | | | [removed: 110,527,311] [added: 110,805,943] | | | | [removed: 109,864,243] [added: 110,527,311] | | |
| BALANCE SHEET DATA [removed: (a)] | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| Total assets | | $ | [removed: 15,028,258] [added: 16,004,253] | | | $ | [removed: 14,288,890] [added: 15,028,258] | | | $ | [removed: 13,486,826] [added: 14,288,890] | | | $ | [removed: 13,357,123] [added: 13,486,826] | | | $ | [removed: 13,089,837] [added: 13,357,123] | |
| Current liabilities | | $ | [removed: 1,442,317] [added: 1,292,946] | | | $ | [removed: 1,559,143] [added: 1,442,317] | | | $ | [removed: 1,618,644] [added: 1,559,143] | | | $ | [removed: 1,083,542] [added: 1,618,644] | | | $ | [removed: 1,342,705] [added: 1,083,542] | |
| Long-term debt less current maturities | | [removed: 3,462,391] [added: 4,021,785] | | | | [removed: 3,006,573] [added: 3,462,391] | | | | [removed: 2,774,605] [added: 3,006,573] | | | | [removed: 3,176,596] [added: 2,774,605] | | | | [removed: 2,997,873] [added: 3,176,596] | | |
| Deferred credits and other | | [removed: 5,404,093] [added: 5,753,610] | | | | [removed: 5,204,072] [added: 5,404,093] | | | | [removed: 4,753,117] [added: 5,204,072] | | | | [removed: 4,994,696] [added: 4,753,117] | | | | [removed: 4,818,673] [added: 4,994,696] | | |
| Total liabilities | | [removed: 10,308,801] [added: 11,068,341] | | | | [removed: 9,769,788] [added: 10,308,801] | | | | [removed: 9,146,366] [added: 9,769,788] | | | | [removed: 9,254,834] [added: 9,146,366] | | | | [removed: 9,159,251] [added: 9,254,834] | | |
| Total equity | | [removed: 4,719,457] [added: 4,935,912] | | | | [removed: 4,519,102] [added: 4,719,457] | | | | [removed: 4,340,460] [added: 4,519,102] | | | | [removed: 4,102,289] [added: 4,340,460] | | | | [removed: 3,930,586] [added: 4,102,289] | | |
| Total liabilities and equity | | $ | [removed: 15,028,258] [added: 16,004,253] | | | $ | [removed: 14,288,890] [added: 15,028,258] | | | $ | [removed: 13,486,826] [added: 14,288,890] | | | $ | [removed: 13,357,123] [added: 13,486,826] | | | $ | [removed: 13,089,837] [added: 13,357,123] | |
| | | [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] | | | | [removed: 2014] [added: 2015] | | | | [removed: 2013] [added: 2014] | | | | [removed: 2012] [added: 2013] | | | | [removed: 2011] [added: 2012] | | |
| Electric operating revenues | | $ | [removed: 3,492,357] [added: 3,489,754] | | | $ | [removed: 3,488,946] [added: 3,492,357] | | | $ | [removed: 3,451,251] [added: 3,488,946] | | | $ | [removed: 3,293,489] [added: 3,451,251] | | | $ | [removed: 3,237,241] [added: 3,293,489] | |
| Fuel and purchased power costs | | [removed: 1,101,298] [added: 1,082,625] | | | | [removed: 1,179,829] [added: 1,101,298] | | | | [removed: 1,095,709] [added: 1,179,829] | | | | [removed: 994,790] [added: 1,095,709] | | | | [removed: 1,009,464] [added: 994,790] | | |
| Other operating expenses | | [removed: 1,779,075] [added: 1,789,149] | | | | [removed: 1,716,325] [added: 1,779,075] | | | | [removed: 1,733,677] [added: 1,716,325] | | | | [removed: 1,693,170] [added: 1,733,677] | | | | [removed: 1,673,394] [added: 1,693,170] | | |
| Operating income | | [removed: 611,984] [added: 617,980] | | | | [removed: 592,792] [added: 611,984] | | | | [removed: 621,865] [added: 592,792] | | | | [removed: 605,529] [added: 621,865] | | | | [removed: 554,383] [added: 605,529] | | |
| Other income | | [removed: 33,332] [added: 46,744] | | | | [removed: 36,358] [added: 33,332] | | | | [removed: 20,797] [added: 36,358] | | | | [removed: 16,358] [added: 20,797] | | | | [removed: 24,974] [added: 16,358] | | |
| Interest expense — net of allowance for borrowed funds | | [removed: 176,109] [added: 183,090] | | | | [removed: 181,830] [added: 176,109] | | | | [removed: 183,801] [added: 181,830] | | | | [removed: 194,777] [added: 183,801] | | | | [removed: 215,584] [added: 194,777] | | |
| Net income | | [removed: 469,207] [added: 481,634] | | | | [removed: 447,320] [added: 469,207] | | | | [removed: 458,861] [added: 447,320] | | | | [removed: 427,110] [added: 458,861] | | | | [removed: 363,773] [added: 427,110] | | |
| Less: Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests | | [removed: 18,933] [added: 19,493] | | | | [removed: 26,101] [added: 18,933] | | | | [removed: 33,892] [added: 26,101] | | | | [removed: 31,613] [added: 33,892] | | | | [removed: 27,524] [added: 31,613] | | |
| Net income attributable to common shareholder | | $ | [removed: 450,274] [added: 462,141] | | | $ | [removed: 421,219] [added: 450,274] | | | $ | [removed: 424,969] [added: 421,219] | | | $ | [removed: 395,497] [added: 424,969] | | | $ | [removed: 336,249] [added: 395,497] | |
| BALANCE SHEET DATA [removed: (a)] | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| Total assets | | $ | [removed: 14,982,182] [added: 15,931,175] | | | $ | [removed: 14,190,362] [added: 14,982,182] | | | $ | [removed: 13,359,517] [added: 14,190,362] | | | $ | [removed: 13,220,050] [added: 13,359,517] | | | $ | [removed: 13,011,056] [added: 13,220,050] | |
| Total equity | | $ | [removed: 4,814,794] [added: 5,037,970] | | | $ | [removed: 4,629,852] [added: 4,814,794] | | | $ | [removed: 4,454,874] [added: 4,629,852] | | | $ | [removed: 4,222,483] [added: 4,454,874] | | | $ | [removed: 4,051,406] [added: 4,222,483] | |
| Long-term debt less current maturities | | [removed: 3,337,391] [added: 4,021,785] | | | | [removed: 2,881,573] [added: 3,337,391] | | | | [removed: 2,649,604] [added: 2,881,573] | | | | [removed: 3,051,596] [added: 2,649,604] | | | | [removed: 2,872,872] [added: 3,051,596] | | |
| Total capitalization | | [removed: 8,152,185] [added: 9,059,755] | | | | [removed: 7,511,425] [added: 8,152,185] | | | | [removed: 7,104,478] [added: 7,511,425] | | | | [removed: 7,274,079] [added: 7,104,478] | | | | [removed: 6,924,278] [added: 7,274,079] | | |
| Current liabilities | | [removed: 1,424,708] [added: 1,094,037] | | | | [removed: 1,532,464] [added: 1,424,708] | | | | [removed: 1,580,847] [added: 1,532,464] | | | | [removed: 1,043,087] [added: 1,580,847] | | | | [removed: 1,322,714] [added: 1,043,087] | | |
(a) During the fourth quarter of 2015, we adopted the new accounting standard related to balance sheet presentation of debt issuance costs.
See further discussion in Note 2.
(a) During the fourth quarter of 2015, we adopted the new accounting standard related to balance sheet presentation of debt issuance costs.
See further discussion in Note 2.
An excerpt. Shown here: 40 of 42 rewritten, all 0 added and all 4 removed. The counts are complete. For every sentence, read Item 6. SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA in the FY2016 filing and the FY2015 filing.
Item 8. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND SUPPLEMENTARY DATA
997 rewritten, 464 added, 314 removed, 1,168 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
| [Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting (Pinnacle West Capital [removed: Corporation)](#s537C242FB42E574B9B9A3B474368CBA5)] [added: Corporation)](#s693F7900038E5A0EB0BB556E9927D24A)] | [removed: [74](#s537C242FB42E574B9B9A3B474368CBA5)] [added: [79](#s693F7900038E5A0EB0BB556E9927D24A)] |
| [Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting [removed: Firm](#s623108AAB8BA58A7B622462EA9888E59)] [added: Firm](#s7F79039A14785D729544CB22D9E3BCF7)] | [removed: [75](#s623108AAB8BA58A7B622462EA9888E59)] [added: [80](#s7F79039A14785D729544CB22D9E3BCF7)] |
| [Pinnacle West Consolidated Statements of Income for [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016, 2015 and](#sAFD3F0D02D285BDBB997D6E8730B3433)] 2014 [removed: and 2013](#s11F069E7BFC3528FA2B8AE5EB37292E6)] | [removed: [77](#s11F069E7BFC3528FA2B8AE5EB37292E6)] [added: [82](#sAFD3F0D02D285BDBB997D6E8730B3433)] |
| [Pinnacle West Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income for [added: 2016,] 2015, [removed: 2014,] and [removed: 2013](#sC99ADE502DD850869282CD0BCF9ED583)] [added: 201](#sC5188C60484D528DA218E2B1E19E279A)4] | [removed: [78](#sC99ADE502DD850869282CD0BCF9ED583)] [added: [83](#sC5188C60484D528DA218E2B1E19E279A)] |
| [Pinnacle West Consolidated Balance Sheets as of December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014](#s68EE69B2C0F25FBCA43A0A09D5F4B236)] [added: 201](#s1D737747BF015082AF6CE82A1D4892A4)5] | [removed: [79](#s68EE69B2C0F25FBCA43A0A09D5F4B236)] [added: [84](#s1D737747BF015082AF6CE82A1D4892A4)] |
| [Pinnacle West Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#sD947832748365CB1B042D874AA82795F)] [added: 201](#s616A2BC90B745368A4D003636B9E3791)4] | [removed: [81](#sD947832748365CB1B042D874AA82795F)] [added: [86](#s616A2BC90B745368A4D003636B9E3791)] |
| [Pinnacle West Consolidated Statements of Changes in Equity for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#s73CF322ACD3B556087FF66991DFC5CE1)] [added: 201](#sCD86FF59870B5F13984E7A0EA7235285)4] | [removed: [82](#s73CF322ACD3B556087FF66991DFC5CE1)] [added: [87](#sCD86FF59870B5F13984E7A0EA7235285)] |
| [Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting (Arizona Public Service [removed: Company)](#sCC6802115CD050B4934D0F41FE7742AA)] [added: Company)](#s0E5989E6C77B57139EA65C1B53EC6ED3)] | [removed: [83](#sCC6802115CD050B4934D0F41FE7742AA)] [added: [88](#s0E5989E6C77B57139EA65C1B53EC6ED3)] |
| [Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting [removed: Firm](#s5F5D9D550B2B59A4AC9851CF02F8076B)] [added: Firm](#sCB6D0EE068445E5DA0BEB5A4EF403C15)] | [removed: [84](#s5F5D9D550B2B59A4AC9851CF02F8076B)] [added: [89](#sCB6D0EE068445E5DA0BEB5A4EF403C15)] |
| [APS Consolidated Statements of Income for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#s37A6876BC2135AC9812CA727F4D287EB)] [added: 201](#s5AD964A4B9A85B1ABC324DE5E7BB3430)4] | [removed: [86](#s37A6876BC2135AC9812CA727F4D287EB)] [added: [91](#s5AD964A4B9A85B1ABC324DE5E7BB3430)] |
| [APS Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#sEC174A105B435C7D8174EEEABE16B198)] [added: 201](#s9B1DEFC353C05581999CADE555D323BB)4] | [removed: [87](#sEC174A105B435C7D8174EEEABE16B198)] [added: [92](#s9B1DEFC353C05581999CADE555D323BB)] |
| [APS Consolidated Balance Sheets as of December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014](#sF1DCBD8F87AC5E478FEFA1DB0C95B42A)] [added: 201](#s04847E9BAF5752D0B82E19CF3FDA1162)5] | [removed: [88](#sF1DCBD8F87AC5E478FEFA1DB0C95B42A)] [added: [93](#s04847E9BAF5752D0B82E19CF3FDA1162)] |
| [APS Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#s1428B3AAB7E15B74B1D07E464286E10D)] [added: 201](#s1799DC1F31FD5DAEB01FF4F2C32F720F)4] | [removed: [90](#s1428B3AAB7E15B74B1D07E464286E10D)] [added: [95](#s1799DC1F31FD5DAEB01FF4F2C32F720F)] |
| [APS Consolidated Statements of Changes in Equity for [removed: 2015, 2014] [added: 2016, 2015] and [removed: 2013](#sE0291142D05259EF9164E705FC6D6129)] [added: 201](#s10A8CAEAB1265C7E8563A76720652BB0)4] | [removed: [91](#sE0291142D05259EF9164E705FC6D6129)] [added: [96](#s10A8CAEAB1265C7E8563A76720652BB0)] |
[removed: | [Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements](#sD732FC25C9D35AC79E2FCBE13601CC5A) | [92](#sD732FC25C9D35AC79E2FCBE13601CC5A) |][added: COMBINED NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS]
| [Note 1. Summary of Significant Accounting [removed: Policies](#sCA3B60DA0B5259CD9DD80332CF96B198)] [added: Policies](#sD0B083D99E8D579A87AB62F3458D3715)] | [removed: [92](#sCA3B60DA0B5259CD9DD80332CF96B198)] [added: [97](#sD0B083D99E8D579A87AB62F3458D3715)] |
| [Note 2. New Accounting [removed: Standards](#sF092D233CE2A566F9324015196C420AA)] [added: Standards](#s51D21E19268A567A8CFEBF329E11958D)] | [removed: [98](#sF092D233CE2A566F9324015196C420AA)] [added: [104](#s51D21E19268A567A8CFEBF329E11958D)] |
| [Note 3. Regulatory [removed: Matters](#s91AFCC6309155AE59FDA91F3C8ADA774)] [added: Matters](#s4882239763985BDEB04205144D8D947D)] | [removed: [99](#s91AFCC6309155AE59FDA91F3C8ADA774)] [added: [106](#s4882239763985BDEB04205144D8D947D)] |
| [Note 4. Income [removed: Taxes](#sA41B1EE67CEA5C92AD5B3D069C399E73)] [added: Taxes](#s9C8759CDA5FB5F5A821C9ED9768F647E)] | [removed: [107](#sA41B1EE67CEA5C92AD5B3D069C399E73)] [added: [118](#s9C8759CDA5FB5F5A821C9ED9768F647E)] |
| [Note 5. Lines of Credit and Short-Term [removed: Borrowings](#sC6B17761E44D57F19F9E514D4F57E33F)] [added: Borrowings](#s01AEBC22D7F65F3C9D89DBB5C45ABD7C)] | [removed: [112](#sC6B17761E44D57F19F9E514D4F57E33F)] [added: [122](#s01AEBC22D7F65F3C9D89DBB5C45ABD7C)] |
| [Note 6. Long-Term Debt and Liquidity [removed: Matters](#s44E3E198D0B05C418FB775F198568AD0)] [added: Matters](#s5EB07A9F51475DCEB6481B804EA8259F)] | [removed: [113](#s44E3E198D0B05C418FB775F198568AD0)] [added: [123](#s5EB07A9F51475DCEB6481B804EA8259F)] |
| [Note 7. Retirement Plans and Other Postretirement [removed: Benefits](#sB52471A9FACC50D7A36FBF72AB01DF6A)] [added: Benefits](#s8A78322BB9AF5D4792BB384C8F3B02AB)] | [removed: [116](#sB52471A9FACC50D7A36FBF72AB01DF6A)] [added: [126](#s8A78322BB9AF5D4792BB384C8F3B02AB)] |
| [Note 9. Jointly-Owned [removed: Facilities](#sE86F6830FA675902BD0A9D004ABDA49C)] [added: Facilities](#sB6B4440D4818531CA6C66016EB81F785)] | [removed: [126](#sE86F6830FA675902BD0A9D004ABDA49C)] [added: [136](#sB6B4440D4818531CA6C66016EB81F785)] |
| [Note 10. Commitments and [removed: Contingencies](#sD9A32219B80359DDA9BFA1F87840CC97)] [added: Contingencies](#sBF5C6E71913B5063B773B6C15FF1232D)] | [removed: [126](#sD9A32219B80359DDA9BFA1F87840CC97)] [added: [137](#sBF5C6E71913B5063B773B6C15FF1232D)] |
| [Note 11. Asset Retirement [removed: Obligations](#s5FD383FB7767540F84FB519167BF5A80)] [added: Obligations](#s43F5F6FB4BE65006956DB5FC9188DF6C)] | [removed: [135](#s5FD383FB7767540F84FB519167BF5A80)] [added: [146](#s43F5F6FB4BE65006956DB5FC9188DF6C)] |
| [Note 12. Selected Quarterly Financial Data [removed: (Unaudited)](#s0724032C64275DDEA2D91240EA3AACA2)] [added: (Unaudited)](#s40FB0BD482EC54C88E5EA78D8E9A1185)] | [removed: [136](#s0724032C64275DDEA2D91240EA3AACA2)] [added: [148](#s40FB0BD482EC54C88E5EA78D8E9A1185)] |
| [Note 13. Fair Value [removed: Measurements](#sD1B306403EA25272B529CD82ADFF9527)] [added: Measurements](#s7206C059A068590E834716933CBD445A)] | [removed: [137](#sD1B306403EA25272B529CD82ADFF9527)] [added: [149](#s7206C059A068590E834716933CBD445A)] |
| [Note 14. Earnings Per [removed: Share](#s3B64087DDAFB5A7CA27DAD815A5C2F38)] [added: Share](#s5D26CEB8BA2D5C0EA9F93AED6D919B63)] | [removed: [144](#s3B64087DDAFB5A7CA27DAD815A5C2F38)] [added: [157](#s5D26CEB8BA2D5C0EA9F93AED6D919B63)] |
| [Note 15. Stock-Based [removed: Compensation](#s251E12E40E685D69A86A4CF42A7EFB93)] [added: Compensation](#s48623D744AEC5B6AB5C8784AD4133FDC)] | [removed: [144](#s251E12E40E685D69A86A4CF42A7EFB93)] [added: [157](#s48623D744AEC5B6AB5C8784AD4133FDC)] |
| [Note 16. Derivative [removed: Accounting](#s7899C4D113355A0A8848524B9DFD077C)] [added: Accounting](#sBA93D85F8FDB5E7FB6A05ADDD880A26E)] | [removed: [147](#s7899C4D113355A0A8848524B9DFD077C)] [added: [160](#sBA93D85F8FDB5E7FB6A05ADDD880A26E)] |
| [Note 17. Other Income and Other [removed: Expense](#s81EB07469B085D4CBB225201936DE1B1)] [added: Expense](#s9DDAE6791C6352D89AD2D40AEFF834C1)] | [removed: [152](#s81EB07469B085D4CBB225201936DE1B1)] [added: [165](#s9DDAE6791C6352D89AD2D40AEFF834C1)] |
| [Note 18. Palo Verde Sale Leaseback Variable Interest [removed: Entities](#s2E73F20973565B7490C503751A7CCD71)] [added: Entities](#s31EF275C3E375B57851C7D6587DBB6A9)] | [removed: [152](#s2E73F20973565B7490C503751A7CCD71)] [added: [166](#s31EF275C3E375B57851C7D6587DBB6A9)] |
| [Note 19. Nuclear Decommissioning [removed: Trusts](#sE2C56E04F1F85ED7A37185864854CB1D)] [added: Trusts](#sB654F340739B5500A8F8E248358ED6D8)] | [removed: [154](#sE2C56E04F1F85ED7A37185864854CB1D)] [added: [167](#sB654F340739B5500A8F8E248358ED6D8)] |
| [Note 20. Changes in Accumulated Other Comprehensive [removed: Loss](#s753e10c81a1d49a482bc1819d9ed3776)] [added: Loss](#sD4E4A46B6CC05D0DBF1906464000C2F3)] | [removed: [155](#s753e10c81a1d49a482bc1819d9ed3776)] [added: [168](#sD4E4A46B6CC05D0DBF1906464000C2F3)] |
Based on our evaluation under the framework in Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013), our management concluded that our internal control over financial reporting was effective as of December 31, [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
The effectiveness of our internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] has been audited by Deloitte & Touche LLP, an independent registered public accounting firm, as stated in their report which is included herein and also relates to the Company’s consolidated financial statements.
We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation and subsidiaries (the “Company”) as of December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014,] [added: 2015,] and the related consolidated statements of income, comprehensive income, changes in equity, and cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
We also have audited the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] based on criteria established in Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.
Our audit of internal control over financial reporting included obtaining an understanding of internal control over financial reporting, assessing the risk that a material weakness [removed: exists] [added: exists,] and testing and evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of internal control based on the assessed risk.
In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation and subsidiaries as of December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014,] [added: 2015,] and the results of their operations and their cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, [removed: 2015,] [added: 2016,] in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America.
| [Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements](#sEA575E78E1BF5B439FCA65C38798699A) | [97](#sEA575E78E1BF5B439FCA65C38798699A) |
| [Note 8. Leases](#s40A7571C8378540491170C30A7C30766) | [134](#s40A7571C8378540491170C30A7C30766) |
February 24, 2017
| February 24, 2017 | |
| | 2016 | | | | 2015 | | |
| | 2016 | | | | 2015 | | |
| Stock compensation | 18,883 | | | | 18,756 | | | | 33,059 | | |
| Change in other long-term liabilities | (82,793 | | ) | | (100,715 | | ) | | (114,052 | | ) |
| Short-term debt borrowings under revolving credit facility | 40,000 | | | | — | | | | — | | |
| Net income | | | | — | | | | | | | — | | | | 442,034 | | | | — | | | | 19,493 | | | | 461,527 | | |
| Issuance of common stock | 296,651 | | | 13,982 | | | | | | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 13,982 | | |
| Purchase of treasury stock (a) | | | | — | | | | (128,105 | ) | | (9,087 | | ) | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | (9,087 | | ) |
| Stock compensation cumulative effect adjustments (See Note 2) | | | | 40,380 | | | | | | | — | | | | 5,475 | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 45,855 | | |
| Balance, December 31, 2016 | 111,392,053 | | | $ | 2,596,030 | | | (55,317 | ) | | $ | (4,133 | ) | | $ | 2,255,547 | | | $ | (43,822 | ) | | $ | 132,290 | | | $ | 4,935,912 | |
February 24, 2017
| February 24, 2017 | |
| | 2016 | | | | 2015 | | |
| Income tax receivable | 11,174 | | | | — | | |
| | 2016 | | | | 2015 | | |
| Total accumulated other comprehensive loss | (25,423 | | ) | | (27,097 | | ) |
| Equity infusion from Pinnacle West | 42,000 | | | | — | | | | — | | |
| Equity infusion from Pinnacle West | | | | — | | | | 42,000 | | | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 42,000 | | |
| Net income | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 462,141 | | | | — | | | | 19,493 | | | | 481,634 | | |
| Stock compensation cumulative effect adjustments (See Note 2) | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 5,411 | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 5,411 | | |
| Balance, December 31, 2016 | 71,264,947 | | | $ | 178,162 | | | $ | 2,421,696 | | | $ | 2,331,245 | | | $ | (25,423 | ) | | $ | 132,290 | | | $ | 5,037,970 | |
4CA is a subsidiary that was formed in 2016 as a result of the purchase of El Paso's 7% interest in Four Corners.
Certain line items are presented in more detail on the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows than was presented in the prior years.
The prior year amounts were reclassified to conform to the current year presentation.
These reclassifications have no impact on net cash flows provided by operating activities.
The following tables show the impacts of the reclassifications of the prior years (previously reported) amounts (dollars in thousands):
| Statement of Cash Flows for the Year Ended December 31, 2015 | As previously reported | | | | Reclassifications to conform to current year presentation | | | | Amount reported after reclassification to conform to current year presentation | | |
| Stock compensation | $ | — | | | $ | 18,756 | | | $ | 18,756 | |
| Statement of Cash Flows for the Year Ended December 31, 2014 | As previously reported | | | | Reclassifications to conform to current year presentation | | | | Amount reported after reclassification to conform to current year presentation | | |
| Cash Flows from Operating Activities | | | | | | | | | | | |
| Stock compensation | $ | — | | | $ | 33,059 | | | $ | 33,059 | |
| Change in other long-term liabilities | (80,993 | | ) | | (33,059 | | ) | | (114,052 | | ) |
lived assets.
- General plant — 7 years.
Contingent losses and environmental liabilities are recorded when it is determined that it is
ASU 2016-09, Stock Compensation: Improvements to Employee Share-Based Payment Accounting
| [Note 8. Leases](#sF0B0490E2E2E521DA926C8A6230F8ACE) | [125](#sF0B0490E2E2E521DA926C8A6230F8ACE) |
February 19, 2016
| February 19, 2016 | |
| Deferred income taxes (Note 4) | 2,723,425 | | | | 2,582,636 | | |
| Change in long-term income tax receivable | — | | | | — | | | | 137,270 | | |
| Balance, December 31, 2012 | 109,837,957 | | | $ | 2,466,923 | | | (95,192 | ) | | $ | (4,211 | ) | | $ | 1,624,102 | | | $ | (114,008 | ) | | $ | 129,483 | | | $ | 4,102,289 | |
| Net income | | | | — | | | | | | | — | | | | 406,074 | | | | — | | | | 33,892 | | | | 439,966 | | |
| Issuance of common stock | 442,746 | | | 24,635 | | | | | | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 24,635 | | |
| Purchase of treasury stock (a) | | | | — | | | | (174,290 | ) | | (9,727 | | ) | | — | | | | — | | | | — | | | | (9,727 | | ) |
February 19, 2016
| February 19, 2016 | |
| Deferred income taxes (Note 4) | 2,764,489 | | | | 2,571,365 | | |
| Change in long-term income tax receivable | — | | | | — | | | | 137,665 | | |
| Liabilities assumed related to acquisition of SCE’s Four Corners’ interest | — | | | | — | | | | 145,609 | | |
| Balance, December 31, 2012 | 71,264,947 | | | $ | 178,162 | | | $ | 2,379,696 | | | $ | 1,624,237 | | | $ | (89,095 | ) | | $ | 129,483 | | | $ | 4,222,483 | |
| Net income | | | | — | | | | — | | | | 424,969 | | | | — | | | | 33,892 | | | | 458,861 | | |
| Other | | | | — | | | | — | | | | (8 | | ) | | — | | | | — | | | | (8 | | ) |
- Other — 7 years.
an offsetting regulatory liability through the settlement period ending December of 2016.
| Liabilities assumed relating to acquisition of SCE Four Corners’ interest (see Note 3) | — | | | | — | | | | 145,609 | | |
In February 2015, new consolidation accounting guidance was issued that amends many aspects of the guidance relating to the analysis and consolidation of variable interest entities.
The new guidance is effective for us, and will be adopted, during the first quarter of 2016; and may be adopted using either a full retrospective or modified retrospective approach.
During the fourth quarter of 2015 we elected to early adopt the following accounting standard updates:
| • | Balance sheet presentation of deferred income taxes. See Note 4. |
| • | Balance sheet presentation of debt issuance costs: Adopted on a retrospective basis, the new guidance requires debt issuance costs to be presented on the balance sheets as a direct reduction to the related debt liabilities. Prior to the adoption of this guidance we were required to present debt issuance costs as an asset on the balance sheets. As a result of adopting this guidance, our December 31, 2015 Consolidated Balance Sheet includes $28 million of debt issuance costs as a reduction to our long-term |
debt.
Our December 31, 2014 Consolidated Balance Sheet presents $25 million of debt issuance costs as a reduction to long-term debt; this amount was previously presented as a component of non-current other deferred debits.
The adoption of this guidance did not impact our results of operations or cash flows.
Debt issuance costs continue to be amortized as interest expense.
Upcoming Rate Case Filing
On January 29, 2016, APS filed a NOI informing the ACC that APS intends to submit a rate case application in June 2016 using an adjusted test year ending December 31, 2015.
The NOI provides an overview of the key issues APS expects to address in its formal request such as rate design changes (residential, commercial and industrial), a decoupling mechanism, permission to defer for potential future recovery costs associated with the Company’s Ocotillo Modernization Project, permission to defer for potential future recovery costs associated with environmental standards compliance, inclusion of post-test year plant and modifications to certain adjustor mechanisms, among other items.
In its rate application, APS will request that its proposed pricing changes take effect in July 2017.
APS is still developing the exact amount of the request.
In 2013, the ACC conducted a hearing to consider APS’s proposal to establish compliance with distributed energy requirements by tracking and recording distributed energy, rather than acquiring and retiring renewable energy credits.
On February 6, 2014, the ACC established a proceeding to modify the renewable
energy rules to establish a process for compliance with the renewable energy requirement that is not based solely on the use of renewable energy credits.
On September 9, 2014, the ACC authorized a rulemaking process to modify the RES rules.
The proposed changes would permit the ACC to find that utilities have complied with the distributed energy requirement in light of all available information.
The ACC adopted these changes on December 18, 2014.
An excerpt. Shown here: 40 of 997 rewritten, 40 of 464 added and 40 of 314 removed. The counts are complete. For every sentence, read Item 8. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND SUPPLEMENTARY DATA in the FY2016 filing and the FY2015 filing.
Item 9A. CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES
5 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 8 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Pinnacle West’s management, with the participation of Pinnacle West’s Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, have evaluated the effectiveness of Pinnacle West’s disclosure controls and procedures as of December 31, [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
APS’s management, with the participation of APS’s Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, have evaluated the effectiveness of APS’s disclosure controls and procedures as of December 31, [removed: 2015.][added: 2016.]
Reference is made to “Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting (Pinnacle West Capital Corporation)” [removed: on page 74] [added: in Item 8] of this report and “Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting (Arizona Public Service Company)” [removed: on page 83] [added: in Item 8] of this report.
Reference is made to “Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” [removed: on page 75] [added: in Item 8] of this report and “Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” [removed: on page 84] [added: in Item 8] of this report on the internal control over financial reporting of Pinnacle West and APS, respectively.
No change in Pinnacle West’s or APS’s internal control over financial reporting occurred during the fiscal quarter ended December 31, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] that materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, Pinnacle West’s or APS’s internal control over financial reporting.
Item 10. DIRECTORS, EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
1 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 4 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Reference is hereby made to “Information About Our Board and Corporate Governance,” “Proposal 1 — Election of Directors” and to “Section 16(a) Beneficial Ownership Reporting Compliance” in the Pinnacle West Proxy Statement relating to the Annual Meeting of Shareholders to be held on May [removed: 18, 2016] [added: 17, 2017] (the [removed: “2016] [added: “2017] Proxy Statement”) and to the “Executive Officers of Pinnacle West” section in Part I of this report.
Item 11. EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
1 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 0 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Reference is hereby made to “Directors’ Compensation,” “Report of the Human Resources Committee,” “Executive Compensation,” and “Human Resources Committee Interlocks and Insider Participation” in the [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] Proxy Statement.
Item 12. SECURITY OWNERSHIP OF
1 rewritten, 0 added, 19 removed, 2 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Reference is hereby made to “Ownership of Pinnacle West Stock” [added: and "Equity Compensation Plan Table"] in the [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] Proxy Statement.
Securities Authorized for Issuance Under Equity Compensation Plans
The following table sets forth information as of December 31, 2015 with respect to the 2012 Plan and the 2007 Plan, under which our equity securities are outstanding or currently authorized for issuance.
Equity Compensation Plan Information
| Plan Category | Number of securities to be issued upon exercise of outstanding options, warrants and rights (a) | | | Weighted- average exercise price of outstanding options, warrants and rights (b) | | | Number of securities remaining available for future issuance under equity compensation plans (excluding securities reflected in column (a)) (c) | |
| Equity compensation plans approved by security holders | 1,611,402 | | | — | | | 2,763,056 | |
| Equity compensation plans not approved by security holders | — | | | — | | | \- | |
| Total | 1,611,402 | | | — | | | 2,763,056 | |
(a) This amount includes shares subject to outstanding performance share awards and restricted stock unit awards at the maximum amount of shares issuable under such awards.
However, payout of the performance share awards is contingent on the Company reaching certain levels of performance during a three-year performance period.
If the performance criteria for these awards are not fully satisfied, the award recipient will receive less than the maximum number of shares available under these grants and may receive nothing from these grants.
(b) The weighted-average exercise price in this column does not take performance share awards or restricted stock unit awards into account, as those awards have no exercise price.
(c) Awards under the 2012 Plan can take the form of options, stock appreciation rights, restricted stock, performance shares, performance share units, performance cash, stock grants, stock units, dividend equivalents, and restricted stock units.
Additional shares cannot be awarded under the 2007 Plan.
However, if an award under the 2012 Plan is forfeited, terminated or canceled or expires, the shares subject to such award, to the extent of the forfeiture, termination, cancellation or expiration, may be added back to the shares available for issuance under the 2012 Plan.
Equity Compensation Plans Approved By Security Holders
Amounts in column (a) in the table above include shares subject to awards outstanding under two equity compensation plans that were previously approved by our shareholders: (a) the 2007 Plan, which was approved by our shareholders at our 2007 annual meeting of shareholders and under which no new stock awards may be granted; and (b) the 2012 Plan, which was approved by our shareholders at our 2012 annual meeting of shareholders.
See Note 15 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for additional information regarding these plans.
Equity Compensation Plans Not Approved by Security Holders
The Company does not have any equity compensation plans under which shares can be issued that have not been approved by the shareholders.
Item 13. CERTAIN RELATIONSHIPS AND RELATED
1 rewritten, 0 added, 0 removed, 1 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Reference is hereby made to “Information About Our Board and Corporate Governance” and “Related Party Transactions” in the [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] Proxy Statement.
Item 14. PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTANT
8 rewritten, 0 added, 2 removed, 9 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
Reference is hereby made to “Accounting and Auditing Matters — Audit Fees and — Pre-Approval Policies” in the [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] Proxy Statement.
| Type of Service | | [removed: 2014] [added: 2015] | | | | [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] | | |
| Audit Fees (1) | | $ | [removed: 2,062,685] [added: 2,014,747] | | | $ | [removed: 2,014,747] [added: 2,137,925] | |
| Audit-Related Fees (2) | | [removed: 212,600] [added: 233,555] | | | | [removed: 233,555] [added: 283,070] | | |
| All Other Fees [removed: (4)] [added: (3)] | | [removed: —] [added: 10,000] | | | | [removed: 10,000] [added: —] | | |
(2) The aggregate fees billed for assurance [added: and related] services that are reasonably related to the performance of the audit or review of the financial statements [removed: that] [added: and] are not included in Audit Fees reported above, which primarily consist of fees for employee benefit plan audits performed in [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] and [removed: 2014.][added: 2015.]
[removed: (4)] [added: (3)] The aggregate fees billed for advice relating to the development of a statement of work for the Company's system integrator for its new Customer Information [removed: System.][added: System in 2015.]
All of the services performed by Deloitte & Touche LLP for APS in [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] were pre-approved by the Audit Committee or the Chair of the Audit Committee consistent with the pre-approval policy.
| Tax Fees (3) | | 8,857 | | | | — | | |
(3) The aggregate fees billed primarily related to tax compliance and tax planning.
Item 15. EXHIBITS AND FINANCIAL STATEMENT SCHEDULES
40 rewritten, 10 added, 2 removed, 277 unchanged
Read the full itemFY2016 item · filed February 24, 2017FY2015 item · filed February 19, 2016
| 10.2.5b | | Pinnacle West APS | | Deferred Compensation Plan of 2005 for Employees of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation and Affiliates (as amended and restated effective January 1, 2016) | | [added: 10.2.5 to Pinnacle West/APS 2015 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473] | | [added: 2/19/2016] |
| 10.3.1b | | Pinnacle West APS | | Pinnacle West Capital Corporation [removed: Supplement] [added: Supplemental] Excess Benefit Retirement Plan, amended and restated as of January 1, 2003 | | 10.7A to Pinnacle West’s 2003 Form 10-K Report, File No. 1-8962 | | 3/15/2004 |
| [removed: 10.3.2b] [added: 10.3.2ab] | | Pinnacle West APS | | [added: First Amendment to the] Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Supplemental Excess Benefit Retirement Plan of 2005 (as amended and restated effective January 1, 2016) | | | | |
| 10.6.4bd | | Pinnacle West APS | | Summary of [removed: 2016] [added: 2017] CEO Variable Incentive Plan and Officer Variable Incentive Plan | | | | |
| [removed: 10.6.6ebd] [added: 10.6.6gbd] | | Pinnacle West | | Form of Performance Share Award Agreement under the Pinnacle West Capital Corporation 2012 Long-Term Incentive Plan | | | | |
| [removed: 10.6.6fbd] [added: 10.6.6hbd] | | Pinnacle West | | Master Amendment to Performance Share Agreements | | 10.3 to Pinnacle West/APS March 31, 2012 Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 5/3/2012 |
| [removed: 10.6.6gbd] [added: 10.6.6ibd] | | Pinnacle West | | Master Amendment to Restricted Stock Unit Agreements | | 10.4 to Pinnacle West/APS March 31, 2012 Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 5/3/2012 |
| [removed: 10.11.1] [added: 10.11.2] | | Pinnacle West [removed: APS] | | Five-Year Credit Agreement dated as of May [removed: 9, 2014,] [added: 13, 2016,] among [removed: APS,] [added: Pinnacle West,] as Borrower, Barclays Bank PLC, as Agent and Issuing Bank, and the lenders and other parties thereto | | [removed: 10.3] [added: 10.1] to Pinnacle West/APS June 30, [removed: 2014] [added: 2016] Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | [removed: 7/31/2014] [added: 8/2/2016] |
| [removed: 10.11.2] [added: 10.11.1] | | Pinnacle West | | Term Loan Agreement dated as of December 31, 2014 among Pinnacle West, as Borrower, JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., as Agent, U.S. Bank Association, as Syndication Agent, TD Bank, N.A., The Bank of Nova Scotia and The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd., as Co-Documentation Agents, and such institutions compromising the lenders party thereto | | 10.11.2 to Pinnacle West/APS 2014 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 2/20/2015 |
| [removed: 10.11.3] [added: 10.11.7] | | Pinnacle West [added: APS] | | Five-Year Credit [removed: Agreement,] [added: Agreement] dated as of May [removed: 9, 2014,] [added: 13, 2016,] among [removed: Pinnacle West,] [added: APS,] as Borrower, Barclays Bank PLC, as Agent and Issuing Bank, and the lenders and other parties thereto | | [removed: 10.4] [added: 10.2] to Pinnacle West/APS June 30, [removed: 2014] [added: 2016] Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | [removed: 7/31/2014] [added: 8/2/2016] |
| 10.11.4 | | Pinnacle West APS | | [removed: Reimbursement] [added: Five-Year Credit] Agreement [added: dated as of September 2, 2015] among APS, [removed: the Banks party thereto, and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.,] as [removed: Administrative] [added: Borrower, Barclays Bank PLC, as] Agent and Issuing Bank, [removed: dated as of April 16, 2010] [added: and the lenders and other parties thereto] | | [removed: 10.2] [added: 10.1] to Pinnacle West/APS [removed: March 31, 2010] [added: September 30, 2015] Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | [removed: 5/6/2010] [added: 10/30/2015] |
| [removed: 10.11.5] [added: 10.11.6] | | Pinnacle West APS | | [removed: Reimbursement] [added: Term Loan] Agreement [added: dated as of April 22, 2016] among APS, [removed: the Banks party thereto, and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.,] as [removed: Administrative] [added: Borrower, Toronto Dominion (Texas) LLC, as] Agent and [removed: Issuing Bank, dated as of April 16, 2010] [added: such institutions compromising the lenders party thereto] | | [removed: 10.3] [added: 10.1] to Pinnacle West/APS March 31, [removed: 2010] [added: 2016] Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | [removed: 5/6/2010] [added: 4/29/2016] |
| [removed: 10.11.6] [added: 10.11.3] | | [removed: APS] [added: Pinnacle West] | | [removed: Five-Year] [added: 364-day] Credit Agreement dated as of [removed: September 2, 2015] [added: August 31, 2016,] among [removed: APS,] [added: Pinnacle West,] as Borrower, [removed: Barclays] [added: The] Bank [removed: PLC,] [added: of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd.,] as Agent and Issuing Bank, and the lenders and other parties thereto | | 10.1 to Pinnacle West/APS September 30, [removed: 2015] [added: 2016] Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | [removed: 10/30/2015] [added: 11/3/2016] |
| [removed: 10.11.7] [added: 10.11.5] | | [added: Pinnacle West] APS | | Term Loan Agreement dated as of June 26, 2015 among APS, as Borrower, Toronto Dominion (Texas) LLC, as Agent, Citibank, N.A., as Syndication Agent, and such institutions compromising the lenders party thereto | | 10.1 to Pinnacle West/APS June 30, 2015 Form 10-Q Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 7/30/2015 |
| Date: February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] | /s/ Donald E. Brandt |
| /s/ Donald E. Brandt | | Principal Executive Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ James R. Hatfield | | Principal Financial Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Denise R. Danner | | Principal Accounting Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Denis A. Cortese | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Richard P. Fox | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Michael L. Gallagher | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Roy A. Herberger, Jr. | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Dale E. Klein | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Humberto S. Lopez | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Kathryn L. Munro | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Bruce J. Nordstrom | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ David P. Wagener | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| Date: February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] | /s/ Donald E. Brandt |
| /s/ Donald E. Brandt | | Principal Executive Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ James R. Hatfield | | Principal Financial Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Denise R. Danner | | Principal Accounting Officer | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Denis A. Cortese | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Richard P. Fox | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Michael L. Gallagher | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Roy A. Herberger, Jr. | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Dale E. Klein | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Humberto S. Lopez | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Kathryn L. Munro | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ Bruce J. Nordstrom | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| /s/ David P. Wagener | | Director | | February [removed: 19, 2016] [added: 24, 2017] |
| 4.6m | | Pinnacle West APS | | Nineteenth Supplemental Indenture dated as of May 6, 2016 | | 4.1 to Pinnacle West/APS May 3, 2016 Form 8-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 5/6/2016 |
| 4.6n | | Pinnacle West APS | | Twentieth Supplemental Indenture dated as of September 20, 2016 | | 4.1 to Pinnacle West/APS September 15, 2016 Form 8-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 9/20/2016 |
| 10.3.2b | | Pinnacle West APS | | Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Supplemental Excess Benefit Retirement Plan of 2005 (as amended and restated effective January 1, 2016) | | 10.3.2 to Pinnacle West/APS 2015 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 2/19/2016 |
| 10.6.6ebd | | Pinnacle West | | Form of Performance Share Award Agreement under the Pinnacle West Capital Corporation 2012 Long-Term Incentive Plan | | 10.6.6e to Pinnacle West/APS 2015 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 2/19/2016 |
| 10.6.6fbd | | Pinnacle West | | Form of Restricted Stock Unit Award Agreement under the Pinnacle West Capital Corporation 2012 Long-Term Incentive Plan | | | | |
| Exhibit No. | | Registrant(s) | | Description | | Previously Filed as Exhibit: a | | Date Filed |
| /s/ Paula J. Sims | | Director | | February 24, 2017 |
| (Paula J. Sims) | | | | |
| /s/ Paula J. Sims | | Director | | February 24, 2017 |
| (Paula J. Sims) | | | | |
| 10.11.4a | | Pinnacle West APS | | Amendment No. 1 to the Reimbursement Agreement among APS, the Banks party thereto, and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., as Administrative Agent and Issuing Bank, dated December 22, 2011 | | 10.11.5a to Pinnacle West/APS 2011 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 2/24/2012 |
| 10.11.5a | | Pinnacle West APS | | Amendment No. 1 to the Reimbursement Agreement among APS, the Banks party thereto, and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., as Administrative Agent and Issuing Bank, dated December 22, 2011 | | 10.11.6a to Pinnacle West/APS 2011 Form 10-K Report, File Nos. 1-8962 and 1-4473 | | 2/24/2012 |